right

left

"In the treasury of nature, there are many Gems; those only are worth carrying away, which we know how to set" --Honigberger

samuelNon Inutilis Vixi (Not lived in vain)
Dr. C. F. Samuel Hahnemann

Minutes of CCH

Minutes of CCHIndex

MINUTES OF THE 52nd MEETING OF THE CENTRAL COUNCIL OF HOMOEOPATHY HELD ON 19th FEBRUARY, 2014 AT NEW DELHI

Present

1 Dr.Ramjee Singh President
2 Dr.Arun Bhasme Vice-President
3 Dr.Prasobh Kumar K.C. Member
4 Dr.Manilal S.
5 Dr.G.Nirmal
6 Dr.M.K.Sahani
7 Dr.Kulwant Singh
8 Dr.G.P.Hahnemann
9 Dr.Narayan Debnath
10 Dr.A.P.Verma
11 Dr. Vinod Kumar
12 Dr. N.Srinivasa Rao
13 Dr.Pankaj Kumar Sharma
14 Dr.Naresh Arora
15 Dr.M.R.Srivatsan "
16 Dr.S.P.Singh
17 Dr.K.K.Juneja
18 Dr.J.K.Patel
19 Dr.Saidul Islam
20 Dr.V.K.Khanna (under court order)
21 Dr.B.N.Prakash
22 Dr.B.N.Singh
23 Dr.L.M.Khan
24 Dr.C.Nayak "
25 Dr.S.M.Desarda
26 Dr.Arvind Kothe (under court order)
27 Dr.L.K.Nanda
28 Dr.Dias Dominic Savio
29 Dr.Chandan Kumar Das
30 Dr.Jose Issac
31 Dr.Veerabramcharya "
32 Dr.V.R.Kawishwar
33 Dr.Bhosale R.N.
34 Dr. Tejinder Pal Singh
35 Dr.Mohammad Zakharia "
36 Dr.N.V.Sugathan "
37 Dr.P.C.Dave "
38 Dr.Girish S.Patel "
39 Dr.Amiya Goswami "
40 Dr.Bharolia Jadvjibhai Muljibhai "
41 Dr.Ghanshyam D.Raval (under court order)
42 Dr.Pinakin N.Trivedi (under court order)
43 Dr.Lalit Verma Secretary

Not Present

1 Dr. Ramesh Chandra Dogra
2 Dr.Ramkrishna Ghosh Mondal
3 Dr.K.V.John
4 Dr.A.U.Ramakrishan
5 Dr.K.K.Kar
6 Dr.Teli Hotu Comdir
7 Dr.V.V.Nagaraja Rao
8 Dr.B.T.Rudresh

At the outset, the Secretary informed that Dr.Sudhir P.K. and Dr.S.Vidhyaprakash have ceased to be members of the Central Council. He also informed that Dr.Ramkrishna Ghosh Mandal and Dr.V.V.Nagaraja have informed their respective inability to attend the meeting.

The Secretary introduced the new members of the Council namely, Dr.Pinakin N.Trivedi, Dr.Ghanshyam D.Raval, Dr.Manilal S. and Dr.Prasobh K.C.

The President, CCH addressed the Council. A copy of his speech is attached herewith as Anneuxre-1

The President, Vice-President and Members present in the meeting alongwith the Secretary and other officials stood in silence for 2 minutes to pay their homage to late Dr. Sibendra Nath Sinha(Member, CCH).

The Central Council started with the Agenda Items as indicated below - :

Agenda Item No. 52.1

  1. Confirmation of the Minutes of the 51st Meeting of the Central Council of Homoeopathy held on 16th August, 2013 at New Delhi.
  2. Comments and Objection regarding minutes of 51st Meeting of CCH from Dr. C. Nayak, and Dr. Ravi N. Bhosale, Members.

The Central Council considered the minutes alongwith comments/objections received from Dr.C.Nayak and Dr.Ravi N.Bhosale and it decided to confirm the minutes subject to reflection of the names i.e. Maharashtra and Gujarat from where the members in the Council in respect of Item No. 5 of the minutes of the meeting of the Education Committee held on 16.4.2013 (Agenda Item No. 51.32 of C.C.H.) stressed for inclusion of Allopathic Pharmacology in the syllabus of BHMS Course (which was not agreed to); and also to add that the re-employed teaching faculty shall work upto 70 years at appropriate place in the proposed amendments in H.C.C.(MSR) Regulations, 2013 in respect of Agenda Item No. 51.8. of said minutes.

Agenda Item No. 52.2

Action taken of the Minutes of the 51st Meeting of the Central Council of Homoeopathy held on 16th August, 2013 at New Delhi.

The Central Council noted Action Taken Report in respect of decisions contained in the minutes of its last meeting held on 16.08.2013.

Agenda Item No. 52.3

The Central Council approved the draft Annual Report subject to the following corrections

  1. Proposed Amendments in Establishment of New Medical College (Opening of New Higher Course or Study or Training and Increase of Admission Capacity by a Medical College) Regulations,2011.

The Central Council considered the matter and approved the draft amendments in Establishment of New Medical College (Opening of New Higher Course or Study or Training and Increase of Admission Capacity by a Medical College) Regulations,2011 as placed herewith as : Anneuxre-2

Agenda Item No. 52.4

Mail letter dated Sept. 15,2013 received from Dr. Mridul Kumar Sahani, Chairman, Education Committee regarding MOU with Super Speciality Hospital.

The Central Council discussed the matter and approved the format of MoU which shall be a part of HCC (MSR) Regulation, and a copy of approved draft is Annexed herewith as Annexure -3

Agenda Item No. 52.5

Main letter dated 15.9.2013 received from Dr. M. K. Sahani, Chairman, Education Committee regarding workshop module to be organized in Colleges by the Council.

The Central Council approved for conducting the workshop on subject namely, Materia Medica for two days duration at S.K. Homoeopathic Medical College, Beed and at J.R.N Rajasthan Vidyapeeth (Deemed) University, Dabok, Udaipur wherein the Resource persons will be Dr.Arvind Kothe, Dr.L.K.Nanda, Dr.P.K.Sudhir, Dr.Verghe Winston, Dr.Vinod Kumar Sangwan, Dr.Manilal Sampat, Dr.Kulwant Singh, Dr.S.K.Bhattacharya, Dr.S.M.Singh and Dr.Swati Bhagwat. The Council decided that the TA/DA to the participants will be borne by C.C.H.

Agenda Item No. 52.6

  1. Ministry's letter No.R.13040/124/2013-HD (Tech.) dated 03.10.2013 regarding Amendment of HCC (MSR) Regulations, 2013.
  2. Ministry's letter No.R.13040/01/2012-HD (Tech.) dated 05.08.2013 regarding Amendment of HCC (MSR) Regulations, 2013.
  3. Letter dated 12.09.2013 received from Dr. M.S. Wane, Prof. & H.O.D. P.B. Homoeopathic Medical College, Chandrapur, regarding the Guidelines to decide the full time teachers and guest teachers in every Department among the existing teaching in reference to CCH Notification of 08.03.2013.
  4. Letters received from Association of Management of Homoeopathic Medical Colleges of Maharashtra reg. representation in terms of decision of Hon'ble High Court of Maharashtra Bench Aurangabad in W.P. No. 4457 of 2013 and C.A. No. 9697 of 2013.
  5. Letter No. AHMC/CCH/13/08/624 dated 30.08.2013 received from Alva's Homoeopathic Medical College, Moodbidri regarding to clarify doubts about BHMS and P.G. Regulations.

The Central Council considered the recommendations of Executive Committee and Education Committee in the matter and also the suggestions received during the meeting and finalized the draft amendments which are annexed herewith as : Anneuxre-4.

Agenda Item No. 52.7

Letter No. DAMS/Homoeopathic College/Land/2013/AYU-2/10778 dated 03.09.2013 received from Govt. of Maharashtra regarding land requirement for Homoeopathic College & attached Hospital.

The Central Council ratified the recommendations of Education Committee in the matter.

Agenda Item No. 52.8

Engagement of Guide/Examiners in M.D.(Hom.) courses for different Universities who were deputed before amendments notified in P. G. Degree Course Regulations during March, 2012.

The Central Council ratified the Resolution made by the P.G.Education Committee which may be incorporated suitably in the amendments in P.G.Degree Course Regulations.

It also decided that the Kerala University of Health Sciences is not appointing the persons who have been holding M.D.(Hom.) qualification in Homoeopathic Philosophy (Organon of Medicine), Materia Medica and Repertory (after taking admission as external candidates) as such the University may be issued a show cause notice before filing a case in the High Court against the University.

Agenda Item No. 52.9

Ministry's letter No. R-13040/92/2008 (HD-Tech) dated 5th June, 2013 regarding National Board of Examinations in Homoeopathy.

The Central Council discussed the matter at length and ratified the recommendation of the P.G.Education Committee for constitution of the National Board of Homoeopathy by the Central Government.

Agenda Item No. 52.10

Providing journey tickets to the members directly for attending the meetings.

The Central Council, after a thorough discussion in the matter, decided that the members will book their own tickets as they have been doing till date and seek reimbursement of the claim from the Office of Central Council.

Agenda Item No. 52.11

Regarding Charging of Periodical Inspection fee for the Period of Five years from April, 2015 from Homoeopathic Medical Colleges..

The Central Council agreed with the suggestion of Education Committee that HCC (MSR) Regulations needs to be amended by allowing inspection of an approved college by the Central Council "after every two years" in place of 5 years.

Agenda Item No. 52.12

Letter dated 01.10.2013 received from Dr. L.K. Nanda Member CCH regarding Module for Materia Medica workshop.
The Central Council approved the Module recommended by the Education Committee on the subject of Materia Medica for the purposes of the Workshop.

Agenda Item No. 52.13

Letters dated 28.11.2013 received from Dr. M.K. Sahani Chairman, Education Committee regarding proposal for a Workshop Exploring New Avenues in Homoeopathic Medical Education alongwith article Revamping Homoeopathic Medical Education Fundamental Considerations.

The Central Council agreed with the recommendations of Education Committee for holding a workshop on "Exploring New Avenues in Homoeopathic Medical Education - Revemping Homoeopathic Medical Education; Fundamental Consideration" wherein Dr.Avinash Pandey, Vice-Chancellor, Bundelkhand University, Professor Ramanarayana, Vice-Chancellor Manipal University, Professor Sudhakar Naik, Director Manipal University, Dr.Arvind Kothe, Former Principal, Shri Kamaxi Devi Homoeopathic Medical College, Shiroda, Professor C.Nayak, former Director General, C.C.R.H., Dr.R.K.Manchanda, Director General C.C.R.H., Dr.M.K.Sahani, G.D.Memorial Homoeopathic Medical College, Dr.Kumar Dhawale and Dr.Munir Ahmed may be invited as Resource persons. The members of Education Committee, P.G.Education Committee and Committee for Excellence in Education in Homoeopathy constituted by C.C.H. will participate in the said workshop. .

Agenda Item No. 52.14

Minister's letter No. R.13014/01/2008-EP(HD) – Part – 1 dated 06.09.2013 regarding Standard format for submission of performance Bank Guarantee.

The Central Council decided not to prescribe any format for submission of Performance Bank Guarantee..

Agenda Item No. 52.15

C.G.H.S. Contribution for the year 2013-2014- regarding.

The Central Council sanctioned Rs. 3,71,393/- for payment of provisional CGHS contribution in respect of Officers and concerned employees of C.C.H.

Agenda Item No. 52.16

Ministry's letter No.R.-13040/10/2011-HD (Tech) dated 12.06.2013 regarding Procedure for consideration of the cases of Homoeopathy Medical Colleges for permission under the provisions of the Homoeopathy Central Council Act, 1973 and H.C.C. (M.S.R.) Regulation, 2013.

The Central Council considered the matter and noted the contents of Ministry's letter No.R.13040/10/2011-HD (Tech.) dated 22.11.2013.

Agenda Item No. 52.17

Ministry's letter No. R.13015/10/1999-HD/CCH (Pt.II) dated 12th October, 2012 regarding clarification sought by CCH in respect of persons who have retired prior to 28.02.2012 in O.A. No. 291/2011.

The Central Council ratified the decision of Executive Committee in the matter.

Agenda Item No. 52.18

  1. Ministry's letter No. R.13040/10/2011-HD (Tech) dated 12.12.2013 regarding inclusion of qualification in Second Schedule of HCC Act, 1973.
  2. Ministry's letter No. R.13040/17/2006-HD dated 17.12.2013 regarding inclusion of qualification in Second Schedule.

The Central Council considered the matter and ratified the decision of Executive Committee taken in its meeting held on 12.2.2014.

Agenda Item No. 52.19

O.M. No.7(2)/E.Coord/2013 dated 18th September,2013 regarding Expenditure Management – Economy Measures and Rationalization of Expenditure.

The Central Council noted the contents of the Office Memorandum of Ministry of Finance regarding economy measures and rationalization of expenditure.

Agenda Item No. 52.20

Ministry's letter No. R. 13040/17/2006-HD dated 16.09.2013 regarding inclusion of BHMS degree qualifications awarded by Dr. Hari Singh Gour Vishwavidyalaya, Sagar in Second Schedule of H.C.C. Act, 1973

The Central Council noted the Gazette Notification published on 21.12.2013 by the Central Government for inclusion of BHMS Degree qualification upto December, 2013.

Agenda Item No. 52.21

Ministry's letter No. R. 13040/93/2008-HD (Tech.) dated 03.09.2013 regarding inclusion of BHMS and M.D. (Hom) degree qualifications awarded by West Bengal University of Health Sciences, Kolkata in Second Schedule of H.C.C. Act, 1973.

The Central Council noted the Gazette Notification published on 03.12.2013 by the Central Government for inclusion of BHMS Degree qualification upto June, 2014.

Agenda Item No. 52.22.

Requests received under Section 12 A of H.C.C. Act for opening of New Homoeopathic Medical Colleges. -

The Central Council considered the matter regarding Jayoti Vidyapeeth Women's University, Jaipur and Navadhar Samajik Sanstha, Dehradun and ratified the decision taken by the Executive Committee. Regarding Vasant Ben Vyas Homoeopathic Medical College, Amreli, the Central Council noted that the applicant organization has yet not submitted the required NOC and Consent of Affiliation of the State Government and University respectively as such advise in the matter may be taken from the Ministry. The President is authorized for sending appropriate letter to Ministry in respect of the applicants organization at Amreli.

 

Agenda Item No. 52.23

Requests received under Section 12 A of H.C.C Act for Higher Courses.

The Central Council noted that the recommendations in respect of Padam Shree Dr.D.Y.Patil Homoeopathic Medical College, Pimpri, Pune; Mahesh Bhattacharya Homoeopathic Medical College, Howrah; Govt.Homoeopathic Medical College, Bangalor; D.S.Homoeopathic Medical College, Pune; White Memorial Homoeopathic Medical College, Attoor, Distt.Kanyakumari; Motiwala (National) Homoeopathic Medical College, Nashik; H.K.E.Society's Homoeopathic Medical College, Gulbarga; Dr.B.D.Jatti Homoeopathic Medical College, Dharwad have been sent to Ministry. Regarding Vamanrao Ithape Homoeopathic Medical College & Hospital, Sangamner the report of inspection has been directly placed in the Councils meeting. The Council after considering the report of inspection decided to recommend for grant of permission to the College for starting M.D.(Hom.) courses in Materia Medica, Organon of Medicine and Practice of Medicine speciality subjects with intake capacity of 3 students in each from the academic year 2014-15

The Council ratified that the Ministry has written to Govt.Homoeopathic Medical College, Bhopal, Anushree Homoeopathic Medical College, Jabalpur, Mangilal Nirban Homoeopathic Medical College, Bikaner and R.V.S.Medical Trust Homoeopathic Medial College, Coimbatore to do the needful by a specified date. As such further action may be taken, if any response is received from the applicants named above.

Agenda Item No. 52.24

Request received under Section 12 A of H.C.C. Act for increase of seats.

The Central Council ratified that the decision of Executive Committee in respect of Padamshree Dr.D.Y.Patil Homoeopathic Medical College (as reflected in the minutes of the Meeting of Executive Committee held on 29.11.2013) for increase in the intake capacity in BHMS Degree Course for which the recommendation has already been sent to Ministry.

The Central Council noted that the E.B.Gadkari Homoeopathic Medical College, Kolhapur is to be inspected shortly as such the Executive Committee may look into the report of inspection for making a recommendation to Ministry on its request.

The Central Council noted that recommendation on the request of Govt.Homoeopathic Medical College, Bangalore and Father Muller Homeopathic Medical College, Mangalore have been sent to Ministry.

It also noted that the Anantrao Kanse Homoeopathic Medical College, Alephata has to be inspected for consideration of the request which may be done as earlier as possible and the report of inspection may be considered by the Executive Committee for making a recommendation to Ministry.

Regarding Govt.Homoeopathic Medical College, Bhopal the required information has yet not been received, therefore, the Council may inform the Ministry accordingly.

Agenda Item No. 52.25

Approval of P.G Examiners for M.D (Hom.) Courses in respect of different Universities.

The Central Council ratified the decision taken by the P.G.Education Committee..

Agenda Item No. 52.26

E-mail letter dated 22.12.2013 received from Dr. C. Nayak, Member P. G. Education Committee regarding approval of Examiners/Guides for M.D.(Hom.) Course under Utkal University.

The Central Council agreed with the recommendation of P.G.Education Committee in the matter.

Agenda Item No. 52.27

Payment above Rs.50,000/-.

The Central Council sanctioned the expost-facto in respect of following payments – :

      (in Rs.)
1.   LTC Expenditure in respect of following officials:-
(i) Shri Kanwar Sain, UDC
(ii) Smt. Veena Khosla, UDC
(iii) Shri Rishi Pal Verma, LDC

73,532.00
55,149.00
55,149.00
2 (i) Post Master, HPO, New Delhi for Postage Stamps in August, 2013 50,000.00
  (ii) Post Master, HPO, New Delhi for Postage Stamps in August, 2013 1,00,000.00
  (iii) Post Master, HPO, New Delhi for Postage Stamps in October, 2013 1,00,000.00
3 (i) M/s. AIM Consultants for providing Man-power during the month of August, 2013 2,27,645.00
  (ii) M/s. AIM Consultants for providing Man-Power during the month of Sept., 2013 2,11,595.00
  (iii) M/s. AIM Consultants for providing Man-Power during The month of Oct., 2013 2,23,590.00
  (iv) M/s. AIM Consultants for providing Man-Power during\ the month of Nov., 2013 2,37,486.00
4.   Accounts Officer, DGACR for Audit Fee for the year 2012-13 55,125.00
5   Smt. Veena Khosla, UDC for reimbursement of medical expenses. 50,456.00
6   M/s. Kendriya Bhandar towards purchase of Stationery Expenses. 75,754.00
7   M/s. Delhi Papers, Delhi for Purchase of Stationery Exp 7. 77,703.00

 

Agenda Item No. 52.28

Letters (bills) dated 06.08.2013 & 11.09.2013 received from Sh. Kundan Kumar Mishra. Regarding LPA No.1630/2012 Union of India Vs. Gyanjyot Education Trust in the High Court of Gujarat at Ahmadabad..

  1. Bill of Rs. 1,78,827 (Rs. 1,05000+Rs. 73,827)
  2. Bill of Rs. 1,53360 (Rs. 1,10,000+Rs. 43360.50)
  3. Bill of Rs. 1,07,341 (Rs. 80,000+ Rs. 27341)
  4. Bill of Rs. 75,000

The Central Council approved the decisions of Executive Committee for making the payments to the Advocate.

Agenda Item No. 52.29

Ministry's letter No. R. 17014/161/2013-EP (H) dated 23.09.2013 regarding R.V.S. Homoeopathic Medical College and Hospital, Sulur, Coimbatore.

The Central Council ratified the decision of Executive Committee in the matter..

Agenda Item No. 52.30

Ministry's order F.No. 1040/04/2010-EP dated 08.10.2013 regarding Shri Gyanjyoti Trust applied for opening of New Homoeopathic Medical College.

The Central Council agreed with the decision of Executive Committee that in respect of letter No. BGGHMC/188/14 dated 20.1.2014 that the applicant may be advised to approach Department of AYUSH, Govt. of India in the matter.

Agenda Item No. 52.31

Ministry's letter No. R.12014/01/2013-EP-(H) dated 30.08.2013 regarding inspection of the A.H. Medical College & Hospital, Begusarai.

The Central Council ratified the decision of Executive Committee in the matter.

 

Agenda Item No. 52.32

Engagement of manpower through outsource agency.

The Central Council ratified the decision of Executive Committee in the matter.

Agenda Item No. 52.33

Appointment of Shri Y.D. Vats, Asstt. Secrtary (A& R) to the post of Dy. Director (Admn.) in the National Water Development Agency on deputation basis

The Central Council noted the legal opinion and reply received from Ministry and it decided that the required action may be taken on priority basis to fill up the temporary vacancy in respect of the post of Assistant Secretary (Administration and Registration).

Agenda Item No. 52.34

Ministry's letter No. R.13040/59/2009-HD (Tech) dated 18.01.2013 regarding amendment in Homoeopathy (Degree Course) Regulations.

The Central Council finalized the draft amendments to Degree Course Regulations annexed herewith as Annexure –5, for sending to Ministry within 15 days.

Agenda Item No.52.35

Amendment in P.G. Regulations.

The Central Council finalized the draft amendments to P.G.Degree Course Regulations annexed herewith as Annexure -6, for sending to Ministry within 15 days.

Agenda Item No. 52.36

Letter dated 21.10.2013 received from Dr. Sandeep Kaila, Secretary, LMHI regarding 69th Congress of LMHI in Paris, France.

The Central Council approved the decision taken by the Executive Committee for deputing its President, Vice-President and Secretary to attend the 69th Congress of LMHI at Paris in France..

Agenda Item No. 52.37

  1. Consideration of Inspection Report of Practice of Medicine Paper I (4thBHMS) Examination to be conducted by the Guru Ghasidas University, Bilaspur.
  2. Consideration of Inspection Report of Homoeopathic Medical Colleges undertaken in view of application received under Section 12 A of HCC Act, 1973
  3. Consideration of Inspection Report of Homoeopathic Medical Colleges undertaken in view of Regulation 3 (7) HCC (MSR) Regulations, 2013.

The Central Council noted the inspections undertaken after 31.12.2013 (which are still continuing) of which reports may be considered by the Executive Committee so that the recommendations and reports can be made available to Ministry in the specified time period.

The Central Council ratified the decisions taken by the Executive Committee in respect of reports of inspections reflected in the Agenda Note regarding examinations and colleges.

Agenda Item No. 52.38

  1. Letter No. MSPHMC/244/12-13 dated 08.02.2013 intimation the change of college name.
  2. Letter No. R. 17014 / 44/2013 – EP (H) dated 19-9-2013 Recognition /NOC regarding the change in the name of college from M.S. Pathak HMC to Pioneer HMC & Hospital, Vadodara.

The Central Council ratified the decisions of Executive Committee in the matter.

Agenda Item No. 52.39

  1. Ministry's letter No. R.12014/04/2012-EP(H) dated 30.05.2012 regarding application of the Devi Ahilya Homoeopathic Medical College & Research Center, Indore for permission of Central Govt. to start a New Homoeopathic Medical College namely Devi Ahilya Homoeopathic Medical College & Research Center, Indore under section 12A of the HCC Act, 1973 -reg.
  2. Ministry's Order R.12014/04/2012-EP (H) dated 14.03.2013 regarding application of the Devi Ahilya Homoeopathic Medical College & Research Center, Indore for permission of Central Govt. to start a New Homoeopathic Medical College namely Devi Ahilya Homoeopathic Medical College & Research Center, Indore under section 12A of the HCC Act, 1973 -reg.
  3. Judgement of Hon'ble High Court of M.P., bench at Indore dated 30.09.2013 in W.P. No.6430 of 2013 (Para Medical Technology Organisation of M.P. Vs. Union of India & Ors.)

Agenda Item No. 52.40

Ministry's letter No. R.13040/66/2012-HD (Tech.) dated 13.09.2013 regarding inclusion of BHMS degree qualification awarded by Himachal Pradesh University, Shimla in Second Schedule of H.C.C. Act,1973

The Central Council ratified the decision of Executive Committee in the matter.

Agenda Item No. 52.41

Enhancement of Interest on G.P.F. Accumulation regarding.

The Central Council ratified the decision of Executive Committee in the matter..

Agenda Item No. 52.42

Minutes of the meeting of the Literature Committee of CCH held on 30.09.2013 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the decisions taken by the Literature Committee.

Agenda Item No. 52.43

Minutes of the meeting of the Education Committee of CCH held on 01.10.2013 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the decisions taken by the Education Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere.

Agenda Item No. 52.44

Minutes of the meeting of the Liaison Committee of CCH held on 04.10.2013 at New Delhi.

The Central Council noted the decisions taken by the Liaison Committee.

Agenda Item No. 52.45

Minutes of the meeting of the Office Functioning Review Committee of CCH held on 07.10.2013 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the decisions taken by the O.F.R. Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere..

Agenda Item No. 52.46

Minutes of the meeting of the P.G. Education Committee of CCH held on 15.10.2013 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the decisions taken by the P.G.Education Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere.

Agenda Item No. 52.47

Minutes of the meeting of the Registration Committee of CCH held on 21.10.2013 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the decisions taken by the Registration Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere.

Agenda Item No. 52.48

Minutes of the meeting of the Excellence in Education Committee of CCH held on 23.10.2013 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the decisions taken by the Excellence in Education Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere.

Agenda Item No. 52.49

Minutes of the meeting of the 160th Executive Committee of CCH held on 25.10.2013 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the decisions taken by the Executive Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere.

Agenda Item No. 52.50

Minutes of the meeting of the Editorial Board Committee of CCH held on 31.10.2013 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the decisions taken by the Editorial Board which have not been discussed elsewhere.

Agenda Item No. 52.51

Minutes of the meeting of the Education Committee of CCH held on 06.11.2013 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the decisions taken by the Education Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere.

Agenda Item No. 52.52

Minutes of the meeting of the Finance Committee of CCH held on 18.11.2013 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the decisions taken by the Finance Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere.

Agenda Item No. 52.53

Minutes of the meeting of the 161th Executive Committee of CCH held on 29.11.2013 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the decisions taken by the Executive Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere.

Agenda Item No. 52.54

Minutes of the meeting of the Office Functioning Review Committee of CCH held on 06.12.2013 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the decisions taken by the O.F.R. Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere.

Agenda Item No. 52.55

Minutes of the meeting of the Education Committee of CCH held on 09.12.2013 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the decisions taken by the P.G.Education Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere.

Agenda Item No. 52.56

Minutes of the meeting of the P.G. Education Committee of CCH held on 23.12.2013 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the decisions taken by the P.G.Education Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere.

Agenda Item No. 52.57

Minutes of the meeting of the Education Committee of CCH held on 30.12.2013 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the decisions taken by the Education Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere.

Agenda Item No. 52.58

Minutes of the meeting of the P.G. Education Committee of CCH to be held on 20.01.2014 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the decisions taken by the P.G.Education Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere.

Agenda Item No. 52.59

Minutes of the meeting of the Education Committee of CCH to be held on 21.01.2014 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the decisions taken by the Education Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere.

Agenda Item No. 52.60

Minutes of the meeting of the Registration Committee of CCH to be held on 29.01.2014 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the decisions taken by the Education Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere.

Agenda Item No. 52.61

Minutes of the meeting of the Education Committee of CCH held on 09.12.2013 at New Delhi.

. The Central Council ratified the decisions taken by the Executive Committee including the grant of following sanctions which have not been discussed elsewhere –

1. M/s. Aim Consultant P. Ltd.
(for providing man power from 12.12.2013 to 31.12.2013)
Rs. 1,55,694/-

The Central Council also granted expost facto sanction in respect of following payments:-

1. Post Master HPO, New Delhi for postage stamps in Dec.,2013 Rs. 1,00,000.00
2. M/s.Aim Consultants for providing Man Power in Dec., 2013 (upto 11.12.2013) Rs. 81,463.00
3. Shri Khushi Ram, LDC towards LTC exp Rs. 72,912.00
4. Homoeopathic Doctors appointed on contract basis namely Rs. 1,01,613.00

Dr.Simmi Gulati, Dr. Sarabjeet Kaur and Dr.Law Kumar Singh towards wage expenses for the month of January, 2014

Agenda Item No. 52.62

Payment of Rs. 4,17,032/- for purchase of Computer, Printer, UPS and Anti-Virus..

The Central Council sanctioned Rs. 4, 17,032/- for payment to M/s. K.S. Infosystems (P) Ltd.

SUPPLEMENTARY AGENDA

Agenda Item No. 52.63.1

Bill No. 3/4/W/77/13 dated 22.11.2012 of Rs. 69,05,900/-

The Central Council sanctioned Rs. 69,05,900/-for payment to Controller of Publications, Delhi subject to availability of funds.

Agenda Item No. 52.63.2

Minutes of the meeting of the Office Functioning Review Committee of Central Council of Homooepathy held on 11.02.2014 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the decisions taken by the O.F.R. Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere.

Agenda Item No. 52.63.3

Minutes of the meeting of the Education Committee of Central Council of Homoeopathy held on 13.02.2014 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the decision taken by the Education Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere.

Agenda Item No. 52.63.4.1

Bill of Rs. 88, 766/- of Speed Post received from Director, New Delhi HPO, New Delhi.

The Central Council sanctioned Rs. 59,176/- payable to Director, New Delhi, HPO, New Delhi towards the bill of Speed Post for January, 2014.

Any other item with the permission of the Chair

  • The Central Council considered the application of a student namely, Nikhila Subhash for transfer from Sharda Krishna Homoeopathic Medial College, Kulasekharam to Father Muller Homoeopathic Medical College, Mangalore and granted the request.
  • The Central Council considered the letter dated NIL of Dr.S.M.Singh seeking Air permission for inspection of Shri T.S.Homoeopathic Medical College, Amravati on 04.07.2013 and granted the request.
  • The Central Council considered the letter dated NIL of Dr.S.M.Singh seeking Air permission for inspection of Devi Ahiliya Homoeopathic Medical College, Indore on 05.11.2013 and granted the request
  • The Central Council allowed payment of T.A. claims of Dr. Vinod Kumar, Member (by car) from his residence to Delhi and back. Meeting ended with a vote of thanks to the chair

    Meeting ended with a vote of thanks to the Chair.

    Sd/-
    (Dr.Ramjee Singh)
    President

    Sd/-
    (Dr.Lalit Verma)
    Secretary
    27.8.2013

EXTRACT TAKEN FROM THE MINUTES OF THE 52ND MEETING
OF
THE CENTRAL COUNCIL OF HOMOEOPATHY HELD ON 19TH FEBRUARY, 2014 AT NEW DELHI.

Agenda Item No. 52.25

Approval of P.G Examiners for M.D (Hom.) Courses in respect of different Universities.

The Central Council ratified the decision taken by the P.G.Education Committee.

Agenda Item No. 52.56

Minutes of the meeting of the P.G. Education Committee of CCH held on 23.12.2013 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the decisions taken by the P.G.Education Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere.

 

MINUTES OF THE 51ST MEETING OF THE CENTRAL COUNCIL OF HOMOEOPATHY HELD ON 16th AUGUST, 2013 AT NEW DELHI

Present

1 Dr.Ramjee Singh President
2 Dr.Arun Bhasme Vice-President
3 Dr.M.K.Sahani Member
4 Dr.Kulwant Singh
5 Dr.A.P.Verma
6 Dr.Pankaj Kumar Sharma
7 Dr.Narayan Debnath
8 Dr.Chandan Kumar Das
9 Dr.Vinod Kumar
10 Dr.Ramesh Chandra Dogra
11 Dr.K.K.Juneja
12 Dr.J.K.Patel
13 Dr.S.P.Singh
14 Dr.Saidul Islam
15 Dr.V.K.Khanna "
16 Dr.B.N.Singh
17 Dr.L.M.Khan
18 Dr.C.Nayak
19 Dr.S.M.Desarda
20 Dr.Jose Issac (under court order)
21 Dr.Veerabramcharya
22 Dr.V.R.Kawishwar
23 Dr.Bhosale R.N.
24 Dr.Amiya Goswami "
25 Dr.Mohammad Zakharia
26 Dr.N.V.Sugathan (under court order)
27 Dr.Arvind Kothe
28 Dr.L.K.Nanda
29 Dr.G.Nirmal
30 Dr.K.K.Kar
31 Dr.Dias Dominic Savio "
32 Dr.Teli Hotu Comdir
33 Dr.Tejinder Pal Singh
34 Dr.P.C.Dave
35 Dr.Girish S.Patel "
36 Dr.M.R.Srivatsan "
37 Dr.Srinivasa Rao "
38 Dr.B.T.Rudresh "
39 Dr.Bharolia Jadvjibhai Muljibhai "
40 Dr.V.V.Nagaraja Rao "
41 Dr.Ghanshyam D.Raval (under court order)
42 Dr.Pinakin N.Trivedi (under court order)
43 Dr.Lalit Verma Secretary

Not Present

1 Dr.S. Vidyaprakash
2 Dr.Naresh Arorar
3 Dr.Sibendranath Sinha
4 Dr.G.P.Hahnemann
5 Dr.Ramkrishna Ghosh Mondal
6 Dr.B.N.Prakash
7 Dr.K.V.John
8 Dr.P.K.Sudhir
9 Dr.A.U.Ramakrishan "

The Secretary, with the permission of Chair, informed that Dr.Ramendra Laskar and Dr.Heenaben Raval have ceased to be the members of Central Council. He introduced Dr.Chandan Kumar Das, and Dr.Bharolia Jadavjibhai Muljibhai as the new members from Tripura and Gujarat States respectively and also informed the re-election of Dr.Teli Hotu Comdir, Dr.J.K.Patel and Dr.Amiya Goswami as members in the Council. He further apprised the Council that the Hon'ble High Court of Gujarat has given the interim relief to the petitioners Dr.Pinakin N.Trivedi and Dr.Ghanshyam D.Raval that they may attend the meeting of Central Council being held on 16.8.2013. The Secretary also informed that members namely Dr.R.K.Ghosh Mondal, Dr.B.N.Prakash and Dr.P.K.Sudhir have informed their respective inability to attend this meeting of the Council.

The President, CCH addressed the Council and informed the activities undertaken after the last meeting of the Central Council of Homoeopathy. A copy of his speech is annexed with these minutes.

The new employee Kumari Kalpana, L.D.C. was introduced to the Council.
The Central Council started with the Agenda Items as indicated below - :

Agenda Item No. 51.1

Confirmation of the Minutes of the 50th Meeting of the Central Council of Homoeopathy held on 19th February, 2013 at New Delhi.

The Central Council confirmed the minutes of its last meeting as circulated.

Agenda Item No. 51.2

Action taken of the Minutes of the 50th Meeting of the Central Council of Homoeopathy held on 19th February, 2013 at New Delhi.

The Central Council noted the Action Taken Report in respect of various decisions reflected in the minutes of its last meeting.

Agenda Item No. 51.3

Draft Annual Report of Central Council of Homoeopathy for the year 2012-13

The Central Council approved the draft Annual Report subject to the following corrections

  1. Under the heading of introduction, in the 5th line, the sign of "," may be placed after the words "Central Register" and before the words "Homoeopathy Central Council Act".
  2. (a) Under the heading of Committees, in the 1st line, the word "entrusted" may be substituted with the words "constituted with".
    (b) under the head of Committees, at point No. 11, the word "Excellency" may be corrected as "Excellence" (at two places).
  3. under the heading of Meetings of Central Council and its Committees during the period under report, at S.No. 3, the word "Committee" may be inserted after the word "Education" and before the word "was".
  4. under the heading of Direct Registration, in the 1st line word "Certificate" may be corrected as "Certificates".
  5. Under the heading of Visits, at S.No.1 , in the 3rd line, the word "Homoeopathic" may be added after the word "concerning" and before the word "medical" . Further in the 3rd line the words "in Homoeopathy" may be substituted with the word "and".
  6. Under the heading of Workshops, at S.No. 8, the word "Uttranchal" may be corrected as "Uttrakhand".
  7. Under the heading of Budget, under the sub-heading of Expenditure, the figure given in front of Non-Plan as "Rs. 489.99" may be read as Rs. "518.91". The sign of "/" may be omitted after the digits shown in front of Non-Plan and Plan respectively.

Agenda Item No. 51.4

Annual Accounts of the Central Council-Audit report of DGACR for the year 2012-13

The Central Council noted the annual accounts and the draft Audit Report of D.G.A.C.R. and also the reply sent to said draft audit report.

Agenda Item No. 51.5

Ministry's Letter No. Z.16011/01/2012-EP(H) dated 24.05.2013 regarding forwarding the applications received under section 12A of HCC Act, 1973 reg.

The Central Council considered the matter and noted that a letter has been sent to Jayoti Vidhyapeeth Womens University, Rajasthan on 14.8.2013 and to Navadhar Samajik Sanstha, Dehradun on 7.8.2013 and to Vasantben N.Vyas Homoeopathic Medical College, Amreli on 11.7.2013 and 7.8.2013 which has been acknowledged but Consent of Affiliation from Uttrakhand Ayurvedic University is awaited, and Om Charitable Chikitsa Samiti, Gwalior on 11.7.2013 to which replies are still awaited. However, Department of AYUSH, Govt. of India in respect of said Om Charitable Chikitsa Samiti has informed that the proposal submitted is for re-inspection as permission was not granted to the proposed college in 2010-11, and in reference to this letter the Central Council decided that the Establishment of new Medical College (Opening of New or Higher Course of Study or Training and increase of Admission capacity by a Medical College) Regulations, 2011 does not provide for re-inspection after the application/scheme has been rejected but the applicant can move a fresh request/application in the matter, and it can be informed to the Central Govt. This factual position may be informed to the Central Govt. before 31st August, 2013 in terms of Schedule given in the Establishment of New Medical College (Opening of New or Higher Course of Study or Training and increase of Admission capacity by a Medical College) Regulations, 2011. The Council also noted no response from North Eastern Institute of Ayurveda and Homoeopathy, Shillong in respect of Central Council's letter dated 10.7.2013 and it has also not sent the Application Fees & no NOC & Consent of Affiliation have been provided, which may also be informed to the Central Govt. that this case can not be processed. The Council decided for undertaking the inspection of the applicant Dr.Ulhas Patil Homoeopathic Medical College and Hospital, Jalgaon to consider the request.

Agenda Item No. 51.6

Requests received under Section 12 A of HCC Act for Higher Courses.

The Central Council considered the matter and noted that the LIC report of the Universities concerned have not been received in respect of Mahesh Bhattacharya Homoeopathic Medical College, Howrah, Govt.Homoeopathic Medical College, Bhopal, Ansushree Homoeopathic Medical College, Jabalpur and Mangilal Nirban Homoeopathic Medical College, Bikaner inspite of written requests. The Council decided that the Central Govt. may be informed and it may be inquired from the Central Govt. whether the Central Council wait for LIC report or proceed for inspection in respect of above named Colleges. In reference to Ministry's letter dated 27.6.2013 in regard to R.V.S.Homoeopathic Medical College, Coimbatore, the Central Council decided that the applicant College need to pay the Application Fees afresh as per provisions of Establishment of new Medical College (Opening of New or Higher Course of Study or Training and increase of Admission capacity by a Medical College) Regulations, 2011 (as Govt.Homoeopathic Medical College, Bangalore paid). The Central Council also noted that the NOC of the respective State Govts. submitted by Vamanrao Ithape Homoeopathic Medical College, Sangamner and Mangilal Nirban Homoeopathic Medical College, Bikaner have not been in the format prescribed in above said Regulations as such it decided till these colleges submit NOC in the prescribed format their applications can not be processed. It further opined that as the Consent of Affiliation of Rajiv Gandhi University of Health Sciences submitted by H.K.E.Society's Homoeopathic Medical College, Gulbarga has been time barred and on the basis of it the application can not be processed, and Central Govt. may be apprised accordingly. However, the Central Council decided for inspection of D.Y.Patil Homoeopathic Medical College, Pimpri, Govt.Homoeopathic Medical College, Bangalore, D.S.Homoeopathic Medical College, Pune, White Memorial Homoeopathic Medical College, Attoor, Kanyakumari, Motiwala (National) Homoeopathic Medical College, Nashik and Dr.B.D.Jatti Homoeopathic Medical College, Dharwad for processing their applications..

Agenda Item No. 51.7

Request received under Section 12 A of HCC Act for increase in intake capacity.

The Central Council noted that the NOC of State Govt. submitted by Anantrao Kanse Homoeopathic Medical College, Pune has not been in the format prescribed in Establishment of New Medical College (Opening of New or Higher Course of Study or Training and increase of Admission capacity by a Medical College) Regulations, 2011 and it also opined that on the basis of said document the application can not be processed. The Central Council noted that the report of inspection of LIC of the concerned Universities have not been submitted with the application of Father Muller Homoeopathic Medical College, Mangalore and Govt.Homoeopathic Medical College, Bhopal and further opined that the Central Govt. may be informed and its guidance may be taken as to whether the Council may proceed for inspection in absence of LIC reports or otherwise. The Council decided for inspection of D.Y.Patil Homoeopathic Medical College, Pimpri, E.B.Gadkari Homoeopathic Medical College, Kolhapur and Govt.Homoeopathic Medical College, Bangalore.

Agenda Item No. 51.8

Gazette Notification of Homoeopathy Central Council (Minimum Standards Requirement of Homoeopathic Colleges and attached Hospitals) Regulations, 2013.

The Central Council considered the matter and it approved the amendments proposed by the Education Committee and P.G.Education Committee in Homoeopathy Central Council (Minimum Standards Requirement of Homoeopathic Colleges and attached Hospitals) Regualations, 2013. However, it desired that further amendments may also be finalized by the Education Committee in respect of Ministry's letter No. R.13040/01/2012-HD(Tech.) dated 2.7.2013. The Central Council also decided that the letter of Maharashtra Federation of Homoeopathic Medical Colleges may be referred to Education Committee for consideration.

Agenda Item No. 51.9

Ministry's letter No. R. 13040/10/2011-HD (Tech.) Pt. dated 10.09.2012 regarding implementation of provisions of Homoeopathy (Minimum Standard of Education) Regulations, 1983 regarding.

The Central Council noted that the Education Committee is considering further amendments in the Standard Information Forms as well as in the format of reporting by the Inspectors/Visitors.

Agenda Item No. 51.10

Consideration of reports of inspection of Homoeopathic Medical Colleges undertaken in view of HCC (MSR) Regulations, 2013.

The Central Council ratified the decision taken by the Executive Committee.

Agenda Item No. 51.11

Amendments in Central Council of Homoeopathy (General) Regulations.

The Central Council ratified the decision taken by the Executive Committee in the matter.

Agenda Item No. 51.12

Ministry's letter No. R.13040/82/2012- HD (Tech.) dated 11.10.2012 regarding Amendments Homoeopathy Central Council (Inspectors & Visitors) Regulations, 1982
The Central Council ratified the decisions taken by the Executive Committee in the matter.

Agenda Item No. 51.13

Reports of Workshop on Organon of Medicine for the teachers of Homoeopathic Medical Colleges held on 22nd to 24th July, 2013 at New Delhi.The Central Council noted the report of the workshop

The Central Council ratified the recommendations made by the Registration Committee in its meeting held on 1.2.2013.

Agenda Item No. 51.14

Approval of P.G Examiners for M.D (Hom.) Courses in respect of different Universities.

The Central Council ratified the decision taken regarding approval of examiners in M.D.(Hom.) examination by the P.G.Education Committee and Executive Committee respectively. However, it decided to approve Dr.Ibrahim Usman Mhaiskar in Repertory subject for M.D.(Hom.) Course of MUHS Nashik as requested by the University vide its letter dated 12.8.2013.

Agenda Item No. 51.15

Consideration of RE for the year 2013-14 and BE for the year 2014-2015 respectively under Plan & Non - Plan.

The Central Council approved the RE for the year 2013-14 and BE for the year 2014-15 under Plan and Non-plan respectively as recommended by the Finance Committee and Executive Committee.

Agenda Item No. 51.16

Payment above Rs.50,000/-

The Central Council granted the expost-facto sanction to the following payments

1 M/s. Aim Consultants Pvt. Ltd. for providing Manpower during the month of March, 2013 1,79,675.00
2 M/s. Aim Consultants Pvt. Ltd. for providing Manpower During the month of April, 2013 1,94,327.00
3 M/s. Aim Consultants Pvt. Ltd. for providing Manpower During the month of May, 2013 2,07,551.00
4 M/s. Aim Consultants Pvt. Ltd. for providing Manpower During the month of June, 2013 2,30,820.00
5 Post Master, HPO, New Delhi in May, 2013 1,00,000.00
6 Post Master, HPO, New Delhi in July, 2013 50,000.00
7 Post Master, HPO, New Delhi in August, 2012 1,00,000.00
8. Gratuity to Smt. V.Soreng, U.D.C. 5,69,052.00
9. Leave Salary to Smt. V.Soreng, U.D.C. 3,28,211.00
10 Final G.P.F. payment to Smt. V.Soreng, U.D.C. 6,91,751.00
11 40% Commutation of Pension to Smt. V.Soreng, U.D.C. 3,76,793.00
12 M/s. Chadha Stationers for Stationery 73,500.00
13 M/s. OST Electronics for purchase of Franking Machine 1,01,026.00
14 M/s. Sidhartha Computers International for purchase of Printers 53,235.00
15 M/s. Kendriya Bhandar for purchase of Stationery items 88,952.00
16 M/s. K.S. Infosystem for installation of CCTV in CCH Premises 67,729.00

.

Agenda Item No. 51.17

Letter No. F.1-74/2009(Anti Ragging) dated 1, May, 2013 from U.G.C.

The Central Council ratified the decision of Education Committee in the matter.

Agenda Item No. 51.18

Amendments in Homoeopathy (Degree Course) Regulations.

The Central Council discussed at length the amendments proposed. However, it decided that the members may send the corrections in the amendments circulated by the Council within a period of 15 days to the Secretary of the Council. It also decided that the so circulated draft amendments may be sent to Members (whose E-mail IDs are available) by E-mail to facilitate the members to do the needful.

Agenda Item No. 51.19

Regarding New subjects for M.D. (Hom.) Course.

The Central Council approved the draft amendments proposed by the P.G.Education Committee for circulation in terms of Section 20 of HCC Act among the State Govts. for their comments. However, the Council passed the following resolution for brining further amendments in the said Regulations

"Teachers of Homoeopathic Colleges who are M.D.in Homoeopathy they will be allowed as Guide/Examiner apart from their teaching subjects in there particular college who is already worked as Guide/Examiner".

Proposed by :-Dr.Ravi N.Bhosale
Seconded by :- Dr.Pankaj C.Dave

Agenda Item No. 51.20

Amendment in Homoeopathy Central Council Act..

The Central Council discussed t.he matter and decided to proposed amendment in Section 3(1)(b) on the analogy of amendments recently notified in Indian Medical Council Act, 1956 allowing a University of Health Sciences to elect one member for each 10 colleges of Homoeopathy as suggested below. However, the maximum limit can be kept upto 5 members if a University has 50 of above Colleges of Homoeopathy

  1. One seat upto 10 colleges
  2. Two seats upto 20 colleges.
  3. Three seats upto 30 colleges.
  4. Four seats upto 40 colleges.
  5. Five seats upto 50 and above.

Agenda Item No. 51.21

D.O. letter No. R.11011/08/2013- EP (IM-1) dated 26th March, 2013 received from Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, Department of AYUSH, Govt. of India, New Delhi regarding process of accreditation-

The Central Council ratified the decision of Education Committee in the matter.:-

Agenda Item No. 51.22.

Letter dated 07.02.2011 received from Biju Pttnaik Govt. Homoeopathic Medical College & Hospital, Orissa regarding award for fellowship in Health Science-

The Central Council ratified the decision of Education Committee in the matter.

 

Agenda Item No. 51.23

Letter No. F. 4/58/Aca./NHMS/2013/513 dated 11.4.2013 received from Govt. of N.C.T of Delhi, Nehru Homoeopathic Medical College & Hospital, New Delhi regarding clarification in respect of H. (M.S.R.)

The Central Council agreed with the decision of Education Committee in the matter. However, it decided that the Education Committee may re-look into all equipment and also look about the substitutes of equipment containing mercury.

Agenda Item No. 51.24

Increase in Inspection fee from the year 2013-2014

The Central Council agreed with the decision of Executive Committee for enhancing the Inspection fees. However, it decided that the President may look into whether in past the two colleges allowed to conduct only PG courses were exempted from paying the additional inspection fees of UG courses and if not then one existing policy may be continued

Agenda Item No. 51.25

Clarification regarding provision of Regulations 11 (vi) of Homoeopathy (Degree Course) Regulations (amended till 2005).

The Central Council decided to follow the provisions of Homoeopathy (Degree Course) Regulations as amended till 2005.

Agenda Item No. 51.26

Approval of Recruitment Rules for the Post of Jr. Hindi Translator and Head Clerk.

The Central Council ratified the decision taken by the Executive Committee in the matter..

Agenda Item No. 51.27

Letter dated 26.02.2013 received from Principal/Director, District Homoeopathic Medical College, Ratlam regarding inspection fee for 2012-2013 for P.G. Coursei.

The Central Council ratified the decision taken by the Executive Committee in the matter.

Agenda Item No. 51.28

Letter dated nil received from Dr. U.K. Verma, Dr. Sunil Naik & Dr. V.K. Dhawan, Visitors regarding submission for verification of complaints of Sh. Ramnath Singh Homeopathic Medical College & Hospital, Gormi, Bhind, M.P.

The Central Council noted the letter sent on 21.6.2013 to Department of AYUSH, Govt. of India in the matter alongwith the report of verification of complaint..

Agenda Item No. 51.29

Minutes of the Meeting of the Committee constituted by Central Council of Homoeopathy to consider Homoeopathy (Minimum Standards Requirement of Homoeopathic Colleges and attached Hospitals) regulations, 2013 and draft amendments in Homoeopathy (Degree Course) Regulations held on 24th & 25th February, 2013 at New Delhi.

The Central Council noted the minutes of the meeting of the Committee constituted to consider the amendments in draft Homoeopathy Central Council (Minimum Standards Requirement of Homoeopathic Colleges and attached Hospitals) Regulations, 2013 and Homoeopathy (Degree Course) Regulations which met on 24th & 25th Feb. 2013. .

Agenda Item No. 51.30

Minutes of the Meeting of Office Functioning Review Committee of Central Council of Homoeopathy held on 05.04.2013 at New Delhi

The Central Council ratified the minutes of the meeting of Office Functioning Review Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere.

Agenda Item No. 51.31

Minutes of the Meeting of P.G. Education Committee of C.C.H. held on 8th April, 2013 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the minutes of the meeting of P.G. Education Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere. However, the Central Council decided that the Secretary may write to all the Universities from which request has been received for implementation of erstwhile PG regulation from 2012-13 for calling the date of admission of students in M.D.(Hom.) Courses for the year 2011-12 in context of Agenda Item No. 5 of said minutes and thereafter the matter may be placed before the P.G. Education Committee.

 

Agenda Item No. 51.32

Minutes of the Meeting of the Education Committee of C.C.H. held on 16th April, 2013 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the minutes of the meeting of Education Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere. In respect of Item No. 5 of the said minutes there has been a long debate wherein the members representing the States of Kerala, Andhra Pradesh, Goa, Punjab, West Bengal, U.P., Bihar, Jharkhand, Odisha, Assam, Tripura, Himachal Pradesh, Haryana and Tamilnadu did not agree for the inclusion of allopathic pharmacology in the syllabus of BHMS Course, and the Council with majority decided accordingly : -

Agenda Item No. 51.33

Minutes of the Meeting of the Committee to Consider Matters Concerning Excellence in Homoeopathy held on 23.04.2013 at New Delhi

The Central Council ratified the minutes of the meeting of Committee to consider matters concerning Excellence in Homoeopathy which have not been discussed elsewhere.

Agenda Item No. 51.34

Minutes of the 157th Meeting of the Executive Committee of the Central Council of Homoeopathy held on 7th & 8th May, 2013 at New Delhi..

The Central Council ratified the decisions of P.G.Education Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere.

Agenda Item No.51.35

Minutes of the Meeting of the Registration Committee of the Central Council of Homoeopathy held on 13th May, 2013 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the minutes of the meeting of Registration Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere.

Agenda Item No. 51.36

Minutes of the Meeting Rajbhasha Hindi Committee of Central Council of Homoeopathy held on 07.06.2013 at New Delhi

The Central Council ratified the minutes of the meeting of Rajbhasha (Hindi) Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere.

Agenda Item No. 51.37

Minutes of the Meeting of the Homoeopathy Literature Committee of the Central Council of Homoeopathy held on 11th June, 2013 at New Delhi

The Central Council ratified the minutes of the meeting of Homoeopathy Literature Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere..

Agenda Item No. 51.38

Minutes of the meeting of the Education Committee of C.C.H. held on 01st July, 2013 at New Delhi

The Central Council ratified the minutes of the meeting of Education Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere.

Agenda Item No. 51.39

Minutes of the Meeting of P.G. Education Committee of C.C.H. held on 03rd July, 2013 at New Delhi..

The Central Council ratified the minutes of the meeting of P.G.Education Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere.

Agenda Item No. 51.40

Minutes of the 158th Meeting of the Executive Committee of the Central Council of Homoeopathy held on 11th July, 2013 at New Delhi

The Central Council ratified the minutes of the meeting of Executive Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere

Agenda Item No. 51.41

Minutes of the Meeting of the Editorial Board for the Journal of Central Council of Homoeopathy (IJHER) held on 23.07.2013 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the minutes of the meeting of Editorial Board. .

Agenda Item No. 51.42

Minutes of the Meeting of the Education Committee of CCH to be held on 24.07.2013 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the minutes of the meeting of Education Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere.

Agenda Item No. 51.43

Minutes of the Meeting of Regulation Committee of the CCH to be held on 30th July, 2013 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the minutes of the meeting of Regulation Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere.

Agenda Item No. 51.44

Minutes of the Meeting of the Finance Committee of C.C.H. to be held on 01st August, 2013 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the minutes of the meeting of Finance Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere.

Agenda Item No. 51.45

Minutes of the 159th Meeting of the Executive Committee of the Central Council of Homoeopathy to be held on 12th August, 2013 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the minutes of the meeting of Executive Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere. However, the Central Council considered the matters concerning Agenda Item Nos. 159.17.11.4, 159.17.11.5 and 159.17.11.6 respectively of these minutes and decided that condonation of delay in completion of internship of one year may be considered if it is within 11 years from the date of admission till completion of internship keeping in view the proposed amendment in Degree Course Regulations, and if it is beyond 11 years than no relaxation may be given. Separately the Central Council also decided to find out as to how MCI and CCIM deals with a student if he has not completed the one year compulsory internship training or if there is a delay in doing so and whether MCI and CCIM have stipulated any maximum period to complete the said compulsory training.

Agenda Item No. 51.46

Ministry's letter No. R 13040/92/2008 (HD-Tech) dated 5th June, 2013 regarding National Board of Examinations in Homoeopathy.

The Central Council noted the Ministry's letter under reference and it decided that the P.G.Education Committee may examine and make available its recommendations in the matter.

Agenda Item No. 51.7

Reports of Workshop for the Principals of Homoeopathic Medical Colleges on the subject 'Homoeopathy Central Council (Minimum Standards Requirement of Homoeopathic Colleges and attached Hospitals) Regulations, 2013 organised by Central Council of Homoeopathy held on 30th March, 2013 and 22nd April, 2013 respectively

The Central Council noted the report of the workshops.

Agenda Item No. 51.48.1

Waiver of Penalty charges on inspection fees from the defaulter Homoeopathic Medical Colleges.

The Central Council agreed with the recommendation of Finance Committee but only for condonation of penalty charges for the first and last time for the defaulter colleges subject to payment of total outstanding principal amount of inspection fees in one attempt in a period of 30 days as recommended by the said Committee. The Council further decided that the Secretary may separately write to Commissioner (AYUSH), Andhra Pradesh for recovery of outstanding inspection fees in respect of Govt. Colleges of the State.

Agenda Item No. 51.48.2

Bill/InvoiceNo.CCH/20/08/2013/030 dated 03.08.2013 regarding payment of Rs. 2, 39,235/- for the month of July, 2013 received from M/s. AIM Consultants Pvt. Ltd..

The Central Council sanctioned an amount of Rs. 2,37,437/- only for payment to M/s.AIM consultant Pvt. Ltd. for the month of July, 2013 against the bill placed before the Council.

Any other item with the permission of the Chair.

The Central Council adopted the following resolutions

  • As per clause 25 of statutes 2003 of West Bengal University of Health Sciences, Central Council of Homoeopathy decided to nominate Dr.Saidul Islam as a member of the Homoeopathic Faculty of West Bengal University of Health Sciences.
    Proposed by :Dr.Narayan Debnath

    Seconded by

    :Dr.Girish S.Patel
    Dr.Pankaj C.Dave
    Dr.C.K.Das
    Dr.M.R.Srivatsan
    Dr.Teli Hotu
    Dr.G.Nirmal

  • The Central Council considered the following matters and decided as reflected below
    (a) Members discussed on the matter raised by Dr.M.R.Srivatsan on the issue of disbursement of TA/DA claims of members'. The Central Council of Homoeopathy decided to disburse the TA/DA claims by cash and also decided to enquire from the Central Council for Research in Homoeopathy regarding the payments of TA Claims and other allowance to the persons attending their meeting/workshop.
    (b) Letter dated 16.8.2013 of Dr.N.V.Sugathan, Member is considered and the Central Council decided that the Secretary may write to the Govt. of NCTE of Delhi as well as to UPSC that the advertisement No. 11/2013 of Union Public Service Commission in respect of vacancies No. 13081122110, 13081123110, 13081124110, 13081125110, 13081126110, 13081127110, 13081128110, 13081129110, 13081130110, 13081131110, 13081132110, published in Employment News of 10-16.8.2013 has been in violation of HCC (MSR) Regulations, 2013 as the essential qualifications and desirable qualifications and experience prescribed in the said regulations have not been reflected in the said advertisement. They may be advised to issue a corrigendum accordingly before selection of candidates.
    (c) The letter dated NIL of Dr.V.Srinivasa Rao and Dr.V.V.Nagaraja Rao, Members is considered and the Central Council decided to include the name of late Dr.G.L.N.Sastry also alongwith other names for Padma Awards.
    (d) The letter dated 14.8.13 of Dr.Vinod Kumar, Member is considered wherein he made a request to allow him to travel by his own car and TA/DA be reimbursed accordingly which the Central Council allowed.

 

Meeting ended with a vote of thanks to the Chair.

Sd/-
(Dr.Ramjee Singh)
President

Sd/-
(Dr.Lalit Verma)
Secretary
27.8.2013

MINUTES OF THE 50th MEETING OF THE CENTRAL COUNCIL OF HOMOEOPATHY HELD ON 19th FEBRUARY, 2013 AT NEW DELHI

Present

1 Dr.Ramjee Singh President
2 Dr.Arun Bhasme Vice-President
3 Dr.M.K.Sahani Member
4 Dr.Kulwant Singh
5 Dr.A.P.Verma
6 Dr.S. Vidyaprakash
7 Dr.G.P.Hahnemann
8 Dr.Pankaj Kumar Sharma
9 Dr.Narayan Debnath
10 Dr.Ramendra Laskar
11 Dr.Vinod Kumar
12 Dr.Ramesh Dogra
13 Dr.K.K.Juneja
14 Dr.J.K.Patel
15 Dr.A.U.Ramakrishan  
16 Dr.S.P.Singh
17 Dr.Saidul Islam
18 Dr.V.K.Khanna
19 Dr.B.N.Prakash
20 Dr.B.N.Singh
21 Dr.L.M.Khan
22 Dr.C.Nayak
23 Dr.S.M.Desarda
24 Dr.Jose Issac (under court order)
25 Dr.Veerabramcharya
26 Dr.V.R.Kawishwar
27 Dr.Bhosale R.N.
28 Dr.Amiya Goswami
29 Dr.Mohammad Zakharia
30 Dr.(Mrs.)Heenaben Raval
31 Dr.N.V.Sugathan (under court order
32 Dr.Arvind Kothe
33 Dr.L.K.Nanda
34 Dr.G.Nirmal
35 Dr.K.K.Kar Secretary
36 Dr.Dias Dominic Savio  
37 Dr.Teli Hotu Comdir  
38 Dr.Tejinder Pal Singh  
39 Dr.P.C.Dave  
40 Dr.Girish S.Patel  
41 Dr.Srinivasa Rao  
42 Dr.Lalit Verma Secretary

Not Present

1 Dr.Naresh Arora
2 Dr.K.P.Mazumdar
3 Dr.M.R.Srivatsan
4 Dr.V.V.Nagaraja Rao
5 Dr.B.T.Rudresh
6 Dr.P.K.Sudhir
7 Dr.Sibendranath Sinha
8 Dr.Ramkrishna Ghosh Mondal
9 Dr.K.V.John "

Before the start of the meeting, as per request of the President, Dr.R.K.Manchanda, the Director General, C.C.R.H. made a presentation before the members of C.C.H. highlighting the need of open mind while deciding policies on education in Homoeopathy as India is the only country in the world to have a strong net working of Homoeopathic Medical Colleges, Universities conducting examinations for the students for award of Degree and Post Graduate Degrees in Homoeopathy, practitioners, manufacturers of Homoeopathic Drugs besides the research activities. He informed that the Govt. of India has given a strong support including the financial and legal one for the development of Homoeopathic System of Medicine which is perhaps a unique example globally. He emphasized that the research work in Homoeopathy can not only be left upon the C.C.R.H. as it has to be a joint venture in which Universities, Homoeopathic Medical Colleges and to some extent Homoeopathic practitioners need to be involved voluntarily. He also focused on various activities in the Govt. sector concerning Homoeopathy in which education in Homoeopathy has to play a key role. If education in Homoeopathy at U.G. level and P.G.level is not strengthened then it may have adverse effect in the time to come on various activities referred to above in the Govt. sectors. He volunteered that the research workers of C.C.R.H. are there to give the required guidance to all Homoeopathic Medical Colleges in the conduct of workshops, symposia etc. related to the research activities. He highlighted the role of computers and internet in all such colleges specially in the P.G.level courses. The members of Central Council appreciated his presentation. The President extended thanks on behalf of C.C.H. to him D.G., CCRH and assured him that all required cooperation will be given from CCH in such activities.

Thereafter all present in the meeting stood in silence for two minutes to pay their homage to late Dr.Mahendra Singh (Member CCH and Chairman, Education Committee), Dr.K.P.Mazumdar(Member, CCH), and also to late Smt. Kiran Bala W/o Shri Rishi Pal, LDC, in CCH office.

The members namely, Dr.M.R.Srivatsan, Dr.P.K.Sudhir, Dr.S.N.Sinha, Dr.V.V.Nagaraja Rao, and Dr.Ramkrishna Gosh Mondal informed their respective inability to attend the meeting

The Secretary informed that Dr.Vimal Kumar Dhawan, Dr.B.Sohan Singh Dr.Rajendra Kanekar Ramesh, Dr.Ghanshyam D.Raval and Dr.P.S.Ranu have ceased to be the members due to completion of their respective terms, and he introduced Dr.Tejinder Pal Singh, Dr.Dias Dominic Savio, Dr.Vinod Kumar and Dr.N. Srinivasa Rao to be newly elected members from their respective States. He also informed about the re-election of Dr.Naryan Debnath, Dr.Pankaj C.Dave and Dr.Girish S.Patel. The Central Council extended a warm welcome to the newly elected and re-elected members .

The President, CCH addressed the Council wherein he greeted the new members and re-elected members and also appreciated the services of the former members whose term has expired. He also highlighted the contributions and role of late Dr.Mahendra Singh and Dr.K.P.Mazumdar, in his speech. He also touched about his meetings with the authorities of Department of AYUSH, Govt. of India regarding various issues, and with the Hon'ble Chief Minister and Hon'ble Health Minister of Kerala State as well as with the Principal Secretary(Health), Bihar. A copy of said speech of the President is enclosed..

The Central Council started with the Agenda items pertaining to this meeting :

Agenda Item No. 50.1

Confirmation of the minutes of the 49th meeting of the Central Council of Homoeopathy held on 28th August, 2012 at New Delhi.

The Central Council confirmed the minutes of its last meeting as circulated.

Agenda Item No. 50.2

Action taken of the minutes of the 49th meeting of the Central Council of Homoeopathy held on 28th August, 2012 at New Delhi.

The Central Council noted the Action Taken Report in respect of various decisions reflected in the the minutes of its last meeting. .

Agenda Item No. 50.3

Ministry's letter No. R.11011/03/2011-E.P. dated 03.09.2012 reg. Establishment of New Homoeopathic Medical Colleges

The Central Council noted the contents of letter received from Department of AYUSH, Govt. of India and the same to be looked into after the notification of Homoeopathy Central Council (Minimum Standards Requirement of Homoeopathic Colleges and attached Hospitals) Regulations, 2013 in the Official Gazette.

Agenda Item No. 50.4

Ministry's letter No. R.Z.28015/83/2012-P&C(AYUSH) dated 3rd September, 2012 regarding Padma Awards, namely Padma Vibhushan, Padma Bhushan and Padma Shri to be announced on the occasion of Republic Day 2013.

The Central Council ratified the names proposed by the President for Padma Awards. However, it resolved as under.

"It is resolved in the 50th Meeting of the Central Council of Homoeopathy, held on 19th Feb. 2013, to congratulate Dr.V.K.Gupta, former member of C.C.H. and also former Principal of Nehru Homoeopathic Medical College for being recipient of Padmashree Award, by the Hon'ble President of India".

Proposed by : Dr.Arvind Kothe
Seconded by: Dr.S.M.Desarda
Dr.Anirudh Verma

Agenda Item No. 50.5

Ministry's letter No. R.13040/126/2011-HD(Tech.) dated 31st October, 2011 regarding inclusion of BHMS degree qualification awarded by Vinoba Bhave University, Hazaribagh (Jharkhand) in Second Schedule of H.C.C. Act, 1973.

The Central Council ratified the decision of Executive Committee for making a recommendation for inclusion of BHMS qualification awarded by Vinoba Bhave University in respect of the students who completed their BHMS Degree Course from Singhbhum Homoeopathic Medical College, Jamshedpur from July, 2008 onwards and Homoeopathic Medical College, Mihijam from 31.8.2009 in the Second Schedule of HCC Act, 1973

Agenda Item No. 50.6

pirYad\ maoM sqaaipt pd\ kinaYz ihndI Anauvaadk sah p`Qaana ilaipk ko pd\ kao badlanao hotU.

The Central Council ratified the decision of Executive Committee taken on 2.11.2012 in the matter.

Agenda Item No. 50.7

  • Ministry's letter No. R.14013/9/2004-HD(Tech.) dated 09.05.2012 regarding Amendment of Homoeopathy (Post Graduate Degree Course) Regulations, 1989.
  • Ministry's letter No. R.14013/9/2004-HD(Tech.) dated 8th October,2012 regarding Amendment of Homoeopathy (Post graduate Degree Course) Regulations,1989-reg.

The Central Council discussed the matter threadbare and it decided after considering the letters of Dr.Ravi M.Nair and Dr.K.K.Kar that the amendments to P.G.Degree Course Regulations had been notified in the Official Gazette after having wide consultations as per provisions of Section 20 of HCC Act, 1973. The amendments in the Regulations is a continuous and progressive process. The feed back about the repercussion of amendments notified in P.G.Degree Course Regulations in March, 2012 from the members of the Central Council is being gathered for consideration. Making of P.G. Degree Courses in other subjects has been felt necessary by the Central Council out of which draft for Community Medicine has earlier been submitted to Central Govt. for sanction. However, now a consolidated draft for all the subjects will be submitted after completion of the requirements of Section 20 of HCC Act, 1973. So far as letter dated 9.5.2012 of the Ministry is concerned the same has been responded vide Central Council's letter No. 19-1/2002-CCH dated 8.1.2013 which may be referred to by the Ministry.

Agenda Item No. 50.8

  • Amendments in Homoeopathy (Minimum Standards of Education) Regulations Correspondence with Ministry.
  • Ministry's letter No. 13040/01/2012-HD (Tech.) dated 18.10.2012 Amendment to Homoeopathy (Minimum Standards of Education regulation.)
  • Ministry's letter No.R.13040/01/2012-HD(Tech.) dated 22.07.2011 regarding amendments in Homoeopathy (Minimum Standards of Education) Regulation.
  • Ministry's letter No.R.13040/01/2012-HD (Tech.) dated 07.12.2012 regarding Meeting notice.

The Central Council decided that a Committee comprising of following members will sit in the office of Central Council on Sunday and Monday i.. 24th and 25th Feb., 2013 to look into the sanctioned regulations received from the Central Government namely, Homoeopathy Central Council (Minimum Standards Requirement of Homoeopathic Colleges and attached Hospitals) Regulations, 2013, to bring out the typographical errors, legal problems as well as other minor corrections without disturbing much in the policy document named above:-

  • Dr. C.Nayak, Member, CCH.
  • Dr.L.K.Nanda, Member, CCH
  • Dr.B.N.Prakash, Member, CCH
  • Dr.S.M.Desarda, Member, CCH
  • Dr.Ravi N.Bhosale, Member, CCH
  • Dr.Arvind Kothe, Member, CCH

The President has desired to issue the notices and agenda to above named members immediately by post and fax/mail and also that these members may be telephonically informed of this Meeting.

The Council also authorize the President to discuss with the authorities of Department of AYUSH on the recommendations/correction required in the sanctioned HCC(Minimum Standards Requirement of Homoeopathic Colleges and attached Hospitals) Regulations, 2013.

Agenda Item No. 50.9

Ministry's letter No. R.13040/40/2012-HD (Tech.) dated 22.03.2012 regarding inclusion of M.D. (Hom.) qualification awarded by Shivaji University, Kolhapur in Second Schedule to H.C.C. Act, 1973.

The Central Council noted the decision of the Executive Committee taken in its meeting held on 2.11.2012 that the examiners for M.D.(Hom.) examinations in respect of Shivaji University have never been approved by the C.C.H. as the University has never approached in the matter to Central Council which has been must as per Post Graduate Degree Course Regulations. However, in view of the fact that the students have already qualified M.D.(Hom.) Courses from the University which has proposed inclusion of M.D.(Hom.) Degree in the subjects namely, Materia Medica, Repertory and Organon of Medicine and Homoeopathic Philosophy in Second Schedule w.e.f. 13.6.2011 as such the same may be accepted and notified in terms of Section 13(2) of HCC Act, 1973.

Agenda Item No. 50.10

Ministry's letter No. R.13015/10/1999-HD/CCH dated 1st October, 2012 regarding representations of Shri Y.D. Vats, Asstt. Secretary and Dr. Ashis Datta for upgradation of Pay Scale to the posts of Assistant Secretary in C.C.H.

TThe Central Council noted the correspondence made between C.C.H. and Department of AYUSH, Govt. of India in the matter and approved the same. However, it decided to wait for a final decision of the Central Govt. to the proposal.

Agenda Item No. 50.11

Ministry's letter No.R.13040/10/2011-HD (Tech.) dated 16.10.2012 regarding summary record of discussion held in a meeting with Executive Committee of CCH on 27.9.2012.

The Central Council noted the summary record of discussions held in Department of AYUSH, Govt. of India on 27.9.2012 with the Executive Committee..

Agenda Item No. 50.12

Bill/Invoice No. CCH/10/10/2012/63 dated 1.10.2012 from M/s. AIM Consultants, New Delhi regarding payment of Rs. 1,80,808/- for the month of September, 2012.
The Central Council granted ex-post-facto sanction to Rs. 1,80,058/- .

Agenda Item No. 50.13

Ministry's letter No.R.14030/29/2005-HD (Tech.) dated 3.10.2012 received from Deputy Secretary to Govt. of India, regarding amendment of Homoeopathy Central Council (Registration) Regulations, 1982.

The Central Council ratified the recommendations made by the Registration Committee in its meeting held on 1.2.2013.

Agenda Item No. 50.14

Ministry's letter No. R.13040/10/2011-HD (Tech.) dated 30.7.2012 regarding inclusion of the names of colleges alongwith names of University in 2nd Schedule IMCC Act, 1970.

The Central Council considered the matter and resolved as under:-

"It is resolved in the 50th Meeting of the Central Council of Homoeopathy that the BHMS & M.D. (Hom.) Degree qualifications awarded by the various Universities, may state the name of the recognized Homoeopathic Colleges, alongwith name of University.

It is also resolved that the qualification awarded by the University may be recognized on onward basis in the interest of the students in respect of their practice as well as employment".

Proposed by:- Dr.Pankaj Kumar Sharma
Seconded by: Dr.S.M.Desarda
Dr. Arvind Kothe
Dr.Tejinder Pal Singh
Dr.Mohd. Zakharia
Dr. Kulwant Singh
Dr.Dominic Dias

Agenda Item No. 50.15

Ministry's letters No. R.13040/10/2011-HD(Tech.) Part dated 15 October, 2012 and No. R.17014/02/2012EP (H) dated 05.10.2012 regarding recommendation CCH for taking action under 19 of the Act in respect of following colleges.

  • Bhagwan Buddha Homoeopathic Medical College, Bangalore.
  • Lokmanya Medical Foundation Homoeopathic Medical College Chinchwad.
  • ASBSS, S.B. Shirkoli Homoeopathic Medical College and Hospital, Sankeshwar.
  • Antarbharti Homoeopathic Medical College (Dabha), Nagpur.
  • Orissa Homoeopathic Medical College, Sambalpur.
  • Venkateswara Homoeopathic Medical College & Hospital (Porur), Chennai.
  • Shri Ramnath Singh Sikha Prassar Samiti Homoeopathic Medical College, Gormi.
  • Homoeopathic Medical College & Hospital, Chandigarh.
  • Vasundhra Raje Homoeopathic Medical College & Hospital, Mahadji Nagar, Shivpuri, Gwalior

The Central Council noted that the reply has been sent to the Ministry vide Central Council's letter No. 15-25/2011-CCH (110-3) dated 22.2.2013. .

Agenda Item No. 50.16

Ministry's Letter No. R.13040/19/2012-HD (Tech.) dated 09.04.2012 regarding inclusion of M.D.(Hom.) qualification awarded by Guru Ravidas University, Hoshiarpur in Second Schedule to HCC Act, 1973.

The Central Council noted the decision of Executive Committee that the University be written to inform the details of Guides and Examiners appointed for the conduct of M.D.(Hom.) courses and examinations. It also noted that Guru Ravi Das Ayurved University has not approached the C.C.H. for approval of Panel of Examiners but it has informed that it appointed the Examiners from the Panel of Baba Farid University of Health Sciences which was approved by the Central Council. Since the students have passed the M.D.(Hom.) examinations and they may not suffer as such the Central Council decided to recommend inclusion of M.D.(Hom.) qualification in Materia Medica, Organon of Medicine & Homoeopathic Philosophy, Repertory from May/June, 2012 till January, 2013.

Agenda Item No. 50.17

Request received under Section 12 A of HCC Act for opening of New Homoeopathy Colleges.

The Central Council noted the decision taken in the matter by the Executive Committee in its meeting held on 18.2.2013 and ratified the same.

Agenda Item No. 50.18

Requests received under Section 12 A of HCC Act for Higher Courses.

The Central Council noted that a response from Ministry about the request of D.S.Homoeopathic Medical College, Pune in view of C.C.H. recommendation sent on 31.8.2012 is yet awaited.

The Central Council noted that the applicant college namely, Narayan Shree Homoeopthic Medical College, Bhopal has not responded to the Council's letter dated 23.1.2013 which needs to be informed to Ministry for a decision as deemed fit.

The Central Council noted the stand of Govt. of India, Department of AYUSH in respect of M.B.Homoeopathic Medical College, Howrah and Govt.Homoeopathic Medical College, Bangalore.

Agenda Item No. 50.19

Request received under Section 12 A of HCC Act for increase intake capacity.

The Central Council considered the matters concerning increase of intake capacity in BHMS course in Ahemednager Homeopathic Medical College, Ahmednagar and it decided to recommend for increase of admission capacity upto 75 students in the said Course as the college has provided the minimum required teaching staff and hospital staff. It also noted the recommendation concerning E.B.Gadkari Homoeopathic Medical College, Gadhiglaj and Govt. Homoeopathic Medical College, Cuddapah by the Executive Committee taken in its meeting held on 18.2.2013 and it ratified the same.

Agenda Item No. 50.20

Approval of P.G.Examiners for M.D.(Hom.) Courses in respect of different Universities.

The Central Council ratified the decisions of P.G.Education Committee as well as Executive Committee in the matter.

Agenda Item No. 50.21

Payment above Rs. 50,000/-

The Central Council granted the expost-facto sanction to the following payments:-

1 M/s. Aim Consultants Pvt. Ltd. for providing Manpower during the month of July, 2012 1,99,193.00
2 M/s. Aim Consultants Pvt. Ltd. for providing Manpower during the month of Aug., 2012 1,86,504.00
3 M/s. Aim Consultants Pvt. Ltd. for providing Manpower during the month of Oct., 2012(including arrears) 2,11,819.00
4 M/s. Aim Consultants Pvt. Ltd. for providing Manpower during the month of Nov., 2012 1,83,036.00
5 Post Master, HPO, New Delhi in Oct, 2012 1,00,000.00
6 Post Master, HPO, New Delhi in Nov., 2012 50,000.00
7 M/s. Web Link India for CCH Website 54,776.00
8 M/s. Kendriya Bhandar towards Stationary items 59,444.00
9 M/s. Kendriya Bhandar towards Stationary items 60,247.00
10 M/S. Delhi Papers towards Stationary Items 63,000.00
11 M/s. Kendriya Bhandar towards Stationary items 77,692.00

Agenda Item No. 50.22.

  • Consideration of Inspection reports of Homoeopathic Medical Colleges in the State of Bihar, Gujarat, Karnataka, Kerala, Madhya Pradesh, Maharashtra, Odisha, Rajasthan, Tamilnadu, Uttar Pradesh, Jharkhand, Assam, Punjab, U.T. Chandigarh and West Bengal, regarding.
  • Consideration of Inspection report of BHMS Examination of Goa University, Goa regarding.
  • Consideration of Inspection Report of (New) Param Himalaya Homoeopathic Medical College, Hospital and Research Center, Dehradun under Section 12 A of HCC, Act,1973.

The Central Council noted the reports of inspection of the listed colleges in view of decisions taken by the Executive Committee in its meeting held on 2.11.2012 and 18.2.2013 respectively subject to the correction by removal of the names of colleges reflected at S.No. 3,4 & 5 in the minutes of the Executive Committee held on 18.2.2013 showing that the reports of the said 3 colleges yet not been received though the said 3 colleges appeared at No. 75,76 & 77 amongst the colleges of which reports of inspection were considered by the Executive Committee.

Agenda Item No. 50.23

Compliance report received from some Homoeopathic Medical Colleges in view of Shortfalls/Observation Reports sent to concerned colleges

The Central Council noted the compliance reports.

Agenda Item No. 50.24

Letter No. R.13040/118/2011-HD (Tech.) dated October, 2011 received from Deptt. of AYUSH, Ministry of Health & Family Welfare, Govt. of India, New Delhi regarding draft regulations for mandatory disclosure for Homoeopathy Colleges and for standards of Staff & other facilities required for Homoeopathy Colleges.

The Central Council ratified the decision of Executive Committee taken in the matter, in its meeting held on 18.2.2013.

Agenda Item No. 50.25

Amendments in Central Council of Homoeopathy (General) Regulations.

The Central Council noted the decision of Executive Committee in the matter.

Agenda Item No. 50.26

Ministry's letter No. R.14040/82/2012-HD (Tech.) dated 11.10.2012 regarding amendments proposed Homoeopathy Central Council (Inspectors and Visitors) Regulations, 1982.

The Central Council noted the decision of the Executive Committee taken on 18.2.2013.

Agenda Item No. 50.27

Report of National Workshop on Dissertation Writing for P.G. Guides organised by CCH in Collabration with Bakson Homoeopathic Medical College , Greater Noida Held on 26th & 27Th September,2012 at New Delhii.

The Central Council noted the report of the workshop and also noted that the Bakson Homoeopathic Medical College has paid the amount asked by the Council .

Agenda Item No. 50.28

Report of Workshop on the subject of Organon of Medicine for the Teachers of Homoeopathic Medical college organized by the Central Council held on 3rd to 5th October, 2012 at New Delhi. .

The Central Council noted the report of the workshop.

Agenda Item No. 50.29

Confirmation of services of employees of the Council.

The Central Council confirmed the services of Dr.Shoukath Ali P.K., Inspector and Shri Satpal Singh, L.D.C.

Agenda Item No. 50.30

  • Bill No. III/IV/113/12 (w) dated 22.11.2012 of Rs. 83, 30,700/-
  • Bill No. III/IV/112/12 (w) dated 09.11.2012 of Rs. 1,90,900/- .

The Central Council sanctioned Rs. 83,30, 700/- and Rs. 1,90,900/- for making the payment to the Publication Department at Delhi.

Agenda Item No. 50.31

Amendments in Recruitment Rules for the post of L.D.C. and Peon in Central Council of Homoeopathy.

The Central Council approved the amendments proposed in the Recruitment Rules for the posts of L.D.C and Peon respectively.

1. M/s. Aim Consultants Pvt. Ltd. for providing Manpower during the month of March, 2012 1,22,927.00 2. M/s. Aim Consultants Pvt. Ltd. for providing Manpower during the month of April, 2012 1,78,893.00 3. M/s. Aim Consultants Pvt. Ltd. for providing Manpower during the month of May, 2012 1,81,799.00 4. M/s. Aim Consultants Pvt. Ltd. for providing Manpower during the month of June, 2012 2,01,049.00 5. Post Master, HPO, New Delhi in May, 2012 50,000.00 6. Post Master, HPO, New Delhi in June, 2012 1,00,000.00 7. Post Master, HPO, New Delhi in August, 2012 1,00,000.00 8. Gratuity to Smt. Raj Kaur, L.D.C. 3,77,883.00 9. Leave Salary to Smt. Raj Kaur, L.D.C. 2,29,020.00 10. Final G.P.F. payment to Smt. Raj Kaur, L.D.C. 7,09,501.00

Agenda Item No. 50.32

Creation of Post of Accounts officer in CCH.

The Central Council considered its own decision taken in its previous meeting to ratify the recommendation/resolution of Regulation Committee that sanctioning of the TA/DA bills of the Councils members unless approved by the Accounts Officer by creation of a post of Accounts Officer, should not be permitted by the Secretary and it decided that the TA/DA bills of the Councils members as well as of other concerned with the business of the Council may be continued to be sanctioned and paid by the Secretary as per rules/regulations. However, the said decision does not mean that the Council does not need the post of Accounts Officer and, therefore, the Central Council reiterated its decision of 28.8.2012 for requesting the concerned authorities of Central Govt. to sanction the following additional posts : -

  • Additional Registrar-cum-Secretary -1
  • Joint Secretary 1
  • Deputy Secretary(Tech.)-1
  • Accounts Officer -1
  • Office Supdt.(Inspection Cell)-1
  • Assistants 5
  • Law Officer -1
  • Data Entry Operator (Assistant Grade)-3

The C.C.H. also decided that for each and every work the Central Govt. may not equate it with the C.C.I.M.

Agenda Item No. 50.33

MReconstitution of various committees of Central Council as per Section 9 (1) of HCC Act, 1973 and General Regulations.

The Central Council constituted the following Committees with the members named there in

EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE

1 Dr. Ramjee Singh President
2 Dr. Arun Bhasme Vice-President
3 Dr. K. K. Juneja Member
4 Dr. S. M. Desarda Member
5 Dr. Narayan Debnath Member
6. Dr. P. C. Dave Member
7. Dr. B. T. Rudresh Member
8 Dr. G. P. Hahnemann Member
9 Dr. Saidul Islam Member

P. G. EDUCATION COMMITTEE

1 Dr. S. P. Singh Member
2 Dr. C. Nayak Member
3 Dr. L. M. Khan Member
4 Dr. V. R. Kawishwar Member
5 Dr. J. K. Patel Member
6. Dr. P. K. Sudhir Member
7. Dr. B. N. Singh Member

EDUCATION COMMITTEE

1 Dr. M. K. Sahani Member
2 Dr. Arvind Kothe Member
3 Dr. Jose Issac Member
4 Dr. L. K. Nanda Member
5 Dr. K. K. Kar Member
6. Dr. A. P. Verma Member
7. Dr. Kulwant Singh Member

FINANCE COMMITTEE

1 Dr. Jose Issac Member
2 Dr. J. K. Patel Member
3 S. N. Sinha Member
4 Dr. Amiya Goswami Member
5 Dr. Veerabramcharya Member
6. Dr. S. Vidyaprakash Member
7. Dr. G. Nirmal Member

REGISTRATION COMMITTEE

1 Dr. P. C. Dave Member
2 Dr. K. K. Juneja Member
3 Dr. A. P. Verma Member
4 Dr. Narayan Debnath Member
5 Dr. Pankaj Kumar Sharma Member
6. Dr. Ramendra Laskar Member
7. Dr. G. Nirmal Member

REGULATION COMMITTEE

1 Dr. R. N. Bhosale Member
2 Dr. B. N. Singh Member
3 Dr(Mrs.) Heenaben Raval Member
4 Dr. Ramesh Dogra Member
5 Dr. Mohammed Zakharia Member
6. Dr. Girish Patel Member

LIAISON COMMITTEE

1 Dr. V. V. Nagarajarao Member
2 Dr. Saidul Islam Member
3 Dr. Teli Hotu Comdir Member
4 Dr. N. V. Sugathan Member
5 Dr. Mohammed Zakharia Member
6. Dr. Dias Dominic Savio Member
7. Dr. G. P. Hahnemann Member

RAJBHASA (HINDI) COMMITTEE

1 Dr. Mohammad Zakaria Member
2 Dr. S. M. Desarda Member
3 Dr. Ramesh Dogra Member
4 Dr. Ramendra Laskar Member
5 Dr. M. R. Srivatsan Member
6. Dr. Pankaj Sharma Member
7. Dr. Heenaben Raval Member

HOMOEOPATHIC LITERATURE COMMITTEE

1 Dr. M. K. Sahani Member
2 Dr. Srinivas Rao Member
3 Dr. L. M. Khan Member
4 Dr. Vinod Kumar Member
5 Dr. B. N. Prakash Member
6. Dr. Dias Dominic Savio Member
7. Dr. P. K. Sudhir Member

OFFICE FUNCTIONING REVIEW COMMITTEE

1 Dr. Arun N. Bhasme Member
2 Dr. M. R. Srivatsan Member
3 Dr. R. N. Bhosale Member
4 Dr. V. R. Kawishwar Member
5 Dr. Girish Patel Member
6. Dr. S. Vidyaprakash Member
7. Dr. Kulwant Singh  

COMMITTEE TO CONSIDER MATTER CONCERNING EXELLENCE IN EDUCATION

1 Dr. Arvind Kothe Member
2 Dr. S. P. Singh Member
3 Dr. V. K. Khanna Member
4 Dr. B. N. Prakash Member
5 Dr. Amiyo Goswami Member
6. Dr. Tejenderpal Singh Member
7. Dr. N. V. Sugathan Member

It also reiterated the decisions taken in the Council's meeting held in March, 2002, March, 2005, March, 2006 and March, 2010 authorizing the President to fill up the vacancies in the said Committees if and when arises in the future.

Agenda Item No. 50.34

Minutes of the Meeting of the P.G. Education Committee of Central Council of Homoeopathy held on 25.09.2012 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the decisions of P.G.Education Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere.

Agenda Item No.50.35

Minutes of the Meeting of the Liaison Committee of Central Council of Homoeopathy held on 31.10.2012 at New Delhi. .

The Central Council noted the minutes of the meeting of the Liaison Committee.

Agenda Item No. 50.36

Minutes of the Meeting of the 155th Executive Committee of Central Council of Homoeopathy held on 02.11.2012 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the decisions of the Executive Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere.

Agenda Item No. 50.37

Minutes of the Meeting of the Literature Committee of Central Council of Homoeopathy held on 09.11.2012 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the decisions taken by the Literature Committee.

Agenda Item No. 50.38

Minutes of the Meeting of the Editorial Board for Publication of Journal, of Central Council of Homoeopathy held on 09.11.2012 at New Delhi

The Central Council considered the recommendations mentioned in the minutes of the meeting of the Editorial board and approved the same subject to that the panel of reviewers will be consulted through letters/mails but no meetings of them will be called in the Central Council.

Agenda Item No. 50.39

Minutes of the Meeting of the Office Functioning Review Committee of the Central Council of Homoeopathy held on 16.11.2012 at New Delhi. .

The Central Council ratified the decisions of O.F.R.Committee reflected in the minutes

Agenda Item No. 50.40

Minutes of the Meeting of the P.G.Education Committee of Central Council of Homoeopathy held on 31.12.2012 at New Delhi

The Central Council ratified the decisions of P.G.Education Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere.

Agenda Item No. 50.41

Minutes of the Meeting of the Committee to consider matters concerning Excellence in Education in Homoeopathy, held on 31.01.2013

The Central Council ratified the decisions of the Committee on Excellence in Education in Homoeopathy.

Agenda Item No. 50.42

Minutes of the Meeting of the Registration Committee of Central Council of Homoeopathy held on 01.02.2013 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the decisions of the Registration Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere.

Agenda Item No. 50.43

Minutes of the meeting of the Finance Committee of the CCH held on 07.02.2013 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the decisions of the Finance Committee except that related to increase in the inspection fees. The decision of Finance Committee regarding increase in the inspection fee has been referred to the Executive Committee.

Agenda Item No. 50.44

Minutes of the Meeting of the P.G.Education Committee of Central Council of Homoeopathy held on 08.02.2013 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the decisions of the P.G.Education Committee (including the draft M.D.(Hom.) Gynaecology and Obstetrics Course) which have not been discussed elsewhere.

Agenda Item No. 50.45

Minutes of the Meeting of the 156th Executive Committee of Central Council of Homoeopathy held on 18.02.2013 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the decisions of the Executive Committee including the Medical Reimbursement claim of Registrar-cum-Secretary which have not been discussed elsewhere and regarding Ministry's letters about sitting allowance it resolved as under:- .

"It is resolved in the 50th Meeting of the Central Council of Homoeopathy held o 19th Feb.,2013 that all the members of Central Council of Homoeopathy be designated as non-officials and their TA/DA of sitting allowance for attending the meetings of the CCH, may be paid accordingly".

Dr.V.R.Kavishwar

Proposed by:Dr.S.P.Singh
Seconded by:
Dr.Arvind Kothe
Dr.B.N.Singh

SUPPLEMENTARY AGENDA

Agenda Item No. 50.46.1

Ministry's letter No.R.13040/59/2009-HD (Tech.) dated 18.01.2013 regarding amendment in Homoeopathy (Degree Course) Regulations .

The Central Council decided that a Committee comprising of following members will sit in the office of Central Council on Sunday and Monday i.e. 24th and 25th Feb., 2013 to look into the draft amendments sent to Central Govt. in respect of Homoeopathy(Degree Course) Regulations recently, to bring out the typographical errors, legal problems as well as other minor corrections (without disturbing much in the document named above) and to circulate it immediately under Section 20 of HCC Act, 1973 with the approval of President.

  • Dr. C.Nayak, Member, CCH.
  • Dr.L.K.Nanda, Member, CCH
  • Dr.B.N.Prakash, Member, CCH
  • Dr.S.M.Desarda, Member, CCH
  • Dr.Ravi N.Bhosale, Member, CCH
  • Dr.Arvind Kothe, Member, CCH

The President has desired to issue the notices and agenda to above named members immediately by post and fax/mail and also that these members may be telephonically informed of this Meeting.

Agenda Item No. 50.45.2

DO Letter No. Z . 28015/01/2013-EP (IM-2) dated 07.01.13 received from Joint secretary Govt. of India , Ministry of Health & Family Welfare, Department of AYUSH) regarding Code of Ethics, Regulations. .

The Central Council considered the matter and approved the draft amendments in Homoeopathic Practitioners (Professional Conduct, Etiquette & Code of Ethics) subject to the following corrections

  • On page 8 of the draft, in Regulation 11(b), no amendment is required
  • On page 9 of the draft, in Regulation 12(4), in the proposed amendment the word "etc." shall be omitted, and further before the word "sutures", the word "applying " may be added, and further before the word "National" the words "participating in" may be added.
  • On page 9 of the draft, in the proposed new regulation 12(A), in the 7th line, the word "Cosmetic" will be read as "Cosmetics", and in the 8th line, after the digits "1940" the words and digits including "Drugs and Cosmetics Rules, 1945" shall be added.
  • On page 20 of the draft, in proposed amendment in Regulation 38(21), in the 7th line, the word "homoeopathic" will be added after the word "registered" and before the word "practitioners".
  • In regulation 38, in the proposed amendments, wherever the words "State Homoeopathic Council" come the sign and word "/Board" may be added.
  • In regulation 38 (4) of the proposed amendments, the word "tributes" need to be corrected as "turpitude".
  • In regulation 38, I n the proposed amendments numbered as 38(7), the words in the brackets shall be corrected as "Drugs & Cosmetics Act".
  • In Regulation 38, in the proposed amendments numbered as 38(12), in the 3rd line, the sign and word "/State" shall be added after the word "Central" and before the word "Government".
  • In the Appendix -2 of the draft, at No. 2, the words "Mental illness Act" may be substituted with the words "Mental Health Act".

 

Agenda Item No. 50.46.3

PDelegation of Financial Powers. .

The Central Council ratified the decision of Executive Committee in the matter. .

Any other Item with the permission of the Chair

The Central Council granted expost-facto-sanction to the following payments :-

  • The Central Council granted expost-facto-sanction to the following payments
    • M/s.Aim Consultants Pvt.Ltd., for providing manpower of the month of December, 2012 Rs. 1,76,357/-
    • Post Master, HPO New Delhi towards purchase of Postage Stamps paid in January, 2013 Rs. 50,000/-
    • NPS Office Contribution & Interest paid in December, 2012 to NSDL (Depository) (paid from March, 2012 to November, 2012) Rs.99,477/-
  • The Central Council in its meeting held on 25.3.2011 decided to appoint 3 Homoeopathic Doctors on temporary but on contractual basis to assist the Registrar/Secretary, Inspector and Assistant Secretary (Technical) which was referred to Ministry, and the Ministry advised vide its letter dated 21.11.10212 to examine the matter in the light of provisions of General Regulations 1984. The regulation 58 of General Regulations deals with appointment of clerical and group 'D' staff and also about the temporary persons as may be required from time to time on the reasonable rates of remuneration provided it does not exceed the rate sanctioned by the Central Govt. for corresponding permanent staff and such appointments shall be subject to ratification by the Council. In the said background, the Central Council decided to appoint 3 Homoeopathic doctors on temporary but contractual basis for an initial period of 6 months extendable to a maximum of another 6 months @ Rs. 35,000/- per month fixed remuneration without any extra payment with 3 casual leaves in six months (without deduction of remuneration) and the contract can be terminated at any time by the Council without prior notice. The appointee shall not be allowed to take any other appointment during the contractual period. In case the appointee is deputed for local or for a work outside Delhi, the local conveyance/TA upto 3rd A.C. train fare can be paid. The Selection Committee for screening the candidates for said posts will comprise upon the President, Secretary and Assistant Secretary (A.R.) and advertisement in one English and one Hindi Newspaper covering NCR region of Delhi can be given for calling the applications.
  • The Central Council resolved as under:-

    "The Council resolves that the MCI be persuaded to allow Homoeopathic graduates and post graduates to have post graduate degree or diploma of six months training or one year experience in Sonography & allowed to function as a Sonologists specially because a person who has done M.Sc. (Pathology) & (Physiology ) & MBBS are permitted for the same as per the MCI Act, 1956.

    Proposed by:Dr.L.K.Nanda
    Seconded by: Dr.K.K.Kar

  • Faxed copy of letter No. GRAU/Registrar/2013/744 dated 19.2.2013 received from Guru Ravidas Ayurved University, Hoshiarpur is considered and the Central Council has no objection for approving the list of the Examiners for M.D.(Hom.) courses run by Guru Ravi Das Ayurved University, Hoshiarpur subject to clearance by the P.G.Education Committee regarding eligibility.

Meeting ended with a vote of thanks to the Chair.

Sd/-
(Dr.Ramjee Singh)
President

Sd/-
(Dr.Lalit Verma)
Secretary
22.2.2013

MINUTES OF THE 49th MEETING OF THE CENTRAL COUNCIL OF HOMOEOPATHY HELD ON 28th AUGAST, 2012 AT NEW DELHI

Present

1 Dr.Ramjee Singh President
2 Dr.Arun Bhasme Vice-President
3 Dr.M.K.Sahani Member
4 Dr.Kulwant Singh
5 Dr.A.P.Verma
6 Dr.Vimal Kumar Dhawan
7 Dr.B.Sohan Singh
8 Dr.Pankaj Kumar Sharma
9 Dr.Naresh Arora
10 Dr.M.R.Srivatsan
11 Dr.S.P.Singh
12 Dr.Saidul Islam
13 Dr.V.K.Khanna
14 Dr.B.N.Prakash
15 Dr.B.N.Singh
16 Dr.L.M.Khan
17 Dr.C.Nayak
18 Dr.S.M.Desarda
19 Dr.Jose Issac
20 Dr.Veerabramcharya
21 Dr.V.V.Nagaraja Rao
22 Dr.V.R.Kawishwar
23 Dr.Bhosale R.N.
24 Dr.Amiya Goswami
25 Dr.Mohammad Zakharia
26 Dr.Heenaben Kartikey Raval
27 Dr.N.V.Sugathan.
28 Dr.Arvind Kothe
29 Dr.L.K.Nanda
30 Dr.G.Nirmal
31 Dr.Ghanshyam D.Raval
32 Dr.K.K.Kar
33 Dr.B.T.Rudresh
Dr.Lalit Verma Secretary

Not Present

1 Dr.K.V.John
2 Dr.K.P.Mazumdar
3 Dr.Ramkrishna Ghosh Mondal
4 Dr. Kanekar Rajendra Ramesh
5 Dr.S. Vidyaprakash
6 Dr.G.P.Hahnemann
7 Dr.Sibendranath Sinha
8 Dr.Mahendra Singh
9 Dr.Narayan Debnath "
10 Dr.Ramesh Dogra "
11 Dr.K.K.Juneja "
12 Dr.Teli Hotu Comdir "
13 Dr.P.S.Ranu "
14 Dr.P.K.Sudhir "
15 Dr.Ramendra Laskar "
16 Dr.J.K.Patel "
17 Dr.A.U.Ramakrishan "

The Secretary, with the consent of the Chair, informed that Dr.Girish S.Patel and Dr.Arun Jadhav have ceased to be the members of the Council, as such the Council appreciated their contribution in the functioning of the Council. The Secretary further introduced the new member namely, Dr.B.T.Rudresh who was welcomed by the Council. The Secretary also informed about the passing away of Dr.P.Banerjee, Member of the Council. The Members and Officials present in the meeting led by President and Vice-President including the Guest (the President of Nursing Council of India) stood up in silence for one minute to pay their homage to the departed soul. The Secretary informed further about the receipt of messages from the Member namely, Dr.Ramakrishana Ghosh Mondal, Dr.Mahednra Singh, Dr.Ramesh Chand Dogra, Dr.S.Vidyaparakash, Dr.S.N.Sinha, Dr.G.P.Hahnemann, Dr.Narayan Debnath, Dr.Laskar and Dr.Teli Hotu for not attending this meeting and these members were granted leave of their absence.

The Secretary informed that the President, C.C.H. has invited Dr. T. Dileep Kumar, President, Indian Nursing Council to share his experience and to suggest ways and means for the regulatory bodies for improved performance & bringing excellence. The President, C.C.H. extended a welcome to Dr. T. Dileep Kumar, President, Indian Nursing Council and also addressed the members and officials of the Central Council high-lighting the various activities of the Council under taken in last five months.

Dr. T. Dileep Kumar, President, Indian Nursing Council spoke at length that by and large the regulatory Councils like Indian Nursing Council are known to conduct inspections and are involved in granting recognition to Colleges, granting permission to increase the intake capacity or otherwise and these Councils spend more of their time in such activities. The regulatory bodies need to look into the related aspects of Regulations and they should find out ways and means even if the same are not prescribed in the respective Act or Regulations. He cited an example that the paucity of senior most teaching faculty in the Nursing Education has been globally noted which include India, and he was amaged to see in Thailand during his visit that his counter part there could make it possible to have some selected senior teaching faculty members to deliver the teaching and training through Video Conferences, and as a matter of result the Indian Nursing Council found it useful and started it in premier Institutions like CMC, Ludhiana and some other institutions at Vellore, Thiruvandrum etc. for P.G.stduents wherein the experts come to the headquarter in the Indian Nursing Council and through Video Conferencing deliver the things which P.G.students in the various Institutions attend. He stated that a Core Committee decides the finalization of topics for the students of Ph.D in Nursing to ensure that the topics are relevant for research outputs for which he cited certain examples. He also stressed that the knowledge for the Medical Profession including the Nursing Profession come from research activities and to improve upon the research activities a Consortium can be planned. He stressed on the need of CME programmes which should be made compulsory for the practitioners. He further stated that allocation of funds from the Govt. authorities and getting them enhanced is quite difficult for which not only persuasion but planning and making of scheme is important. He accepted that Homoeopathy has a greater following amongst the public, bureaucrates and the political personalities therefore, getting support for Homoeopathy in the National Health Policy and National Rural Health Mission may not be difficult . He expressed his thanks for giving an opportunity to speak before the august House of Central Council of Homoeopathy as a matter of privilege.

Thereafter the Central Council started with its Agenda :

Agenda Item No. 49.1

Confirmation of the minutes of the 48th meeting of the Central Council of Homoeopathy held on 21st March, 2012 at New Delhi.

The Central Council confirmed the minutes of its last meeting as circulated.

Agenda Item No. 49.2

Action taken of the minutes of the 48th meeting of the Central Council of Homoeopathy held on 21st March, 2012 at New Delhi.

The Central Council noted with satisfaction the Action Taken Report in respect of the minutes of its last meeting.

Agenda Item No. 49.3

Draft Annual Report of Central Council of Homoeopathy of the year 2011-12

The Central Council approved the draft Annual Report for the year 2011-12 subject to following correction/decisions :-

  1. In the list of Members, the name of Dr.Ravi N.Bhosale needs to be included.
  2. Under the heading of Workshops in the draft, only first 4 points may be retained but the 5th point may be de-linked from the workshops heading and a separate heading of RFD may be given.
  3. The E-mail IDs provided by the members may be also reflected in the list of Members with the name of concerned member. Dr.C.Nayak was requested to meet the Secretary to look into if any, grammatical mistake in the said report exist and if that can be corrected

Agenda Item No. 49.4

Annual Accounts of the Council for the year 2011-12.

The Central Council ratified the Annual Accounts as approved by the Executive Committee and it also noted the decision of Executive Committee on the Audit Report.

Agenda Item No. 49.5

Request received under Section 12 A of HCC Act for opening of new Homoeopathy Colleges.

The Central Council considered the report of inspection of Devi Ahiliya Homoeopathic Medical College, Indore and Dr.Ulhas Patil Homoeopathic Medical College, Jalgaon and after considering the reports of inspection it noted that Devi Ahiliya Homoeopathic Medical College, Indore can be allowed to start BHMS Degree Course with intake capacity of 50 students provided the applicant make available 'Consent of Affiliation' of University in the prescribed format and appoint teachers (who have consented) besides appointing supporting staff as prescribed for laboraties and establish clinical pathology laboratory in attached Hospital. It decided that a recommendation may be made to Central Govt. alongwith the report of Inspection. However, it noted that the Ulhas Patil Homoeopathic Medical College, Jalgaon does not fulfill the minimum requirements to start BHMS Degree Course as it has been functioning from the premises of the Medical College being run by its management and IPD functioning is reported unsatisfactory as not found genuinely functional and, therefore, the Central Govt. may not allow it at present for starting admission of students in BHMS Degree Course. The report of inspection of Ulhas Patil Homoeopathic Medical College may be sent to the Ministry.

The Central Council also noted that the consent of affiliation of the University in respect of the proposed College of Nav Adhar Samajic Sansthan, Dehradun is neither in the prescribed format nor there has been any report of the LIC of the University. The College has not responded to the letters sent by Central Council till date and further when the Council decided to undertake inspection of the said Institution then it received the request letter from the applicant for postponing the inspection. It may be informed to Ministry with copies of all relevant correspondence with this applicant.

Agenda Item No. 49.6

Request received under Section 12 A of HCC Act for Higher Courses.

The Central Council considered the report of inspection of D.S.Homoeopathic Medial College, Pune and also noted the incomplete and faulty NOC of the State Govt.. Subject to making available the NOC of State Govt. strictly as per prescribed format the Central Council recommended for grant of approval to this College for starting M.D.(Hom.) Course in the speciality subject of Practice of Medicine, with intake capacity of three students only per annum. The Council noted that the NOC provided by the applicant Narayan Shree Homeopathic Medical College, Bhopal from State Govt. has not been in order and Consent of Affiliation of University is also not in prescribed format as such it approved the recommendation of the Executive Committee for taking up the matter with the Ministry. Regarding Mahesh Bhattacharya Homoeopathic Medical College, Howrah and Govt.Homoeopathic Medical College, Bangaluru, the Central Council noted that the applications received from these two State Govt. Colleges have not been processed for want of application fees and it may be informed to the Ministry.

The Central Council ratified the recommendation of Executive Committee for allowing Dr. Rambalak Singh Gaya Homoeopathic Medical College, Gaya for admission of three students per annum in M.D. (Hom) Courses in subjects namely Organon of Medicine and Repertory.

 

Agenda Item No. 49.7

Request received under Section 12 A of HCC Act for increase intake capacity.

The Central Council noted that the NOC provided by the Ahmednagar Homoeopathic Medical College from the State Govt. has not been in order if compared with the format prescribed in Establishment of New Medical College (Opening of New or Higher Course of Study or Training and Increase of Admission Capacity by a Medical College) Regulation, 2011and for such reasons further action can not be initiated at present. Even the Consent of Affiliation of the University has been found not in the prescribed format, therefore, the Council decided to inform the same to Ministry.

Agenda Item No. 49.8

Ministry's letter No. R.13040/45/2010-HD(Tech) dated 20.03.2012 regarding inclusion of BHMS degree qualification awarded by Maharshi Dayanand University, Rohtak in the Second Schedule to H.C.C. Act, 1973.

The Central Council ratified the decision of Executive Committee for inclusion of BHMS Degree qualification of Maharishi Dayanand University in the Second Schedule for July, 2010 to February, 2015.

Agenda Item No. 49.9

Ministry's Letter No. R-13040/10/2011-HD (Tech.) dated 4th May, 2012 regarding W.P. No. 1562/11, Chandola Homoeopathic Medical College Vs. Union of India & Ors.

The Central Council ratified the decisions taken by the Executive Committee from time to time in the matter.

Agenda Item No. 49.10

Ministry's letter No.13040/93/2008-HD(Tech.)dated 20.3.2012 regarding inclusion of BHMS Degree qualification awarded by the West Bengal University of Health Sciences, Kolkata in Second Schedule of HCC Act, 1973.

The Central Council ratified the decisions of Executive Committee in the matter.

Agenda Item No. 49.11

Ministry's letter No. V.27021/5/87-Homoeo.-II dated 03.04.2012 regarding inclusion of M.D. (Hom.) qualification awarded by Babasaheb Bhimrao Ambedkar Bihar University, Muzaffarpur, Bihar in Second Schedule of HCC Act, 1973.

The Central Council ratified the decision of Executive Committee in the matter.

Agenda Item No. 49.12

  1. Ministry's letter No. V.27013/2/2011-EP (IM-2) dated 21.11.2011
    regarding inclusion of the names of Colleges along with names of University in 2nd Schedule of IMCC Act, 1970.
  2. Ministry's letter No. R.13040/10/2011-HD (Tech.) dated 30.07.2012.

The Central Council considered the matter and it authorized the President to discuss it in the Ministry with the Secretary (AYUSH) Govt. of India. The Office of the Council may prepare a note and hand over the same to President for discussions in the Ministry.

Agenda Item No. 49.13

Ministry's letter No. R-13040/59/2012-HD(Tech) dated 04.05.2012 regarding Orders of the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India dated 09.01.2012 in SLP (Civil) No. 23350 of 2011 title as Department of AYUSH & Ors. Vs. Acharya Gyan Ayurvedic College, Talawali Chanda, Indore, Madhya Pradesh filed by the Department of AYUSH against the order dated 20.12.2010 passed by the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi in LPA No. 899/2010.

The Central Council agreed with the decision of Executive Committee in the matter.

Agenda Item No. 49.14

Amendments in Homoeopathy (Minimum Standards of Education) Regulations Correspondence with Ministry. Ministry' letter No. R.13040/29/2005-HE (Tech.) dated 22.07.2011 regarding amendment in Homoeopathy (Minimum Standards of Education) Regulation

Ministry's letter No. R.13040/01/2012-HD dated 20.04.2012 regarding amendment in Homoeopathy (Minimum Standards of Education) Regulation.

The Central Council discussed the matter in depth and it decided to approve the draft amendments subject to the following changes :-

  1. The name of these Regulations shall be "Homoeopathy (Minimum Standards of Education) Amendment Regulations, or the year may be suffixed as and when these have to be notified".
  2. Point 15 in the draft Regulations shall be omitted.
  3. The paragraph at point 3 in the draft Regulations shall be substituted with the following paragraphs

    " Referral hospital the college and attached hospital shall fulfill the minimum requirements, norms and standards in terms of accommodation, land, equipment, teaching staff and other staff as well as training hospital facilities (including functioning Operation Theatre and Labor Room) prescribed in these regulations. The concerned college and attached hospital shall have tie up with the near by reputed hospital of Modern Medicine having all required facilities of Operation Theater, Labor Room, ICU and Diagnostic equipment for the management of critical patients if they can not be treated in the attached homoeopathic hospital in emergency conditions.

  4. In Schedule 2 of the draft, at S.No. 2 the post shall be re-designated as Deputy Superintendent/Senior Medical Officer. The post of Pathologist and Biochemist at S.No. 9 & 10 will be placed as Pathologist/Biochemist. The Hospital staff shown as X-ray Technician/Radiographer, X-ray Attendant and Yoga Expert besides Physiotherapist may be put "on call". The minimum number of Nursing staff for 25 beds shall be reduced to 4.
  5. In Schedule 4 of this draft regulations the total number of teachers on full time basis shall be 28 for 100 students and no difference for 50/100 intake is needed.
  6. In Schedule 7 of the draft Regulations, at point 6, under the heading of Lecturer, under the heading Essential qualification, the words "preferably in the concerned subject" shall be prefixed after the words "Post Graduate Qualification in Homoeopathy". For the same S.No., under the heading of age the figure "35" shall be substituted with the figure "40".
  7. The Lecturer & Assistant Professor Posts will be redesignated as "Asstt. Professor and Associate Professor" respectively in the Regulations.

The Central Council ratified the decisions of Executive Committee.

Agenda Item No. 49.15

Draft M.D. (Hom.) Course in New Subjects in Homoeopathy (Post Graduate Degree Course) Regulations.

The Central Council discussed the matter at length and it decided that the corrections suggested by Dr.C.Nayak, Member in writing may be incorporated in the draft regulations and it approved the draft for taking further action in the matter. The Central Council also allowed to substitute Surgery with Practice of Medicine as an optional subject in M.D.(Hom.) Physiology, and to include Homoeopathic Materia Medica as an optional subject for M.D.(Hom.) Community Medicine.

Agenda Item No. 49.16

  1. Consideration of inspection reports of Homoeopathic Medical Colleges in the States of Andhra Pradesh, Bihar, Chandigarh, Gujarat, Kerala, Karnataka, Madhya Pradesh, Maharashtra, Odisha, Rajasthan Tamilnadu, and West Bengal.

  2. Consideration of report of inspection of Examination of Final BHMS Exam (suplt) the West Bengal University of Health Science Kolkata subject Practice of Medicine II.

  3. Consideration of Inspection report of M.D. (Hom.) Part-I & II Viva and Clinical Examination June, 2012 conducted by the Vinayaka Mission University, Salem at the Vinayaka Mission's Homoeopathic Medical College, Salem reg.

The Central Council ratified the decisions taken by the Executive Committee on reports of inspection.

Agenda Item No. 49.17

Amendments in Central Council of Homoeopathy (General) Regulations.

The Central Council deferred the matter for its next meeting in the light of decision taken by the Executive Committee.

Agenda Item No. 49.18

Reports of Workshop for the Principals of P.G. Centres & P.G. Guides on 18.06.2012 & Workshop for the teachers on Organon of Medicine of Homoeopathic Philosophy organized by CCH 12th to 14th July, 2012 at New Delhi.

The Central Council noted the reports of the workshops.

Agenda Item No. 49.19

Approval of P.G. Examiners for M.D. (Hom.) Courses in respect of different Universities.

The Central Council ratified the decisions reflected in the Agenda Note.

Agenda Item No. 49.20

Ministry's letter No. R.13040/10/2011-HD (Tech.) (Part) dated 27.05.2011 regarding poor admission in BHMS Degree Course at National Level Involvement of CBSE in BHMS admission.

The Central Council decided that for the time being entrance examination for BHMS Degree Course through CBSE is not required.

Agenda Item No. 49.21

Ministry's letter No. R.13040/49/2009-HD(Tech.) dated 02.01.2012 regarding inclusion of M.D. (Hom.) degree in the subject or "Organon of Medicine" qualification awarded by Bharti Vidyapeeth University, Pune in the Second Schedule of H.C.C. Act, 1973.

The Central Council ratified the decision of Executive Committee in the matter.

Agenda Item No. 49.22.

Consideration of RE for the year 2012-13 and BE for the year 2013-14 respectively under Plan & Non-Plan.

The Central Council approved the Revised Estimates and Budget Estimates under Plan and Non-Plan for the years 2012-13 and 2013-14 as recommended by the Finance Committee and Executive Committee.

Agenda Item No. 49.23

Proposal for purchase of New Computer, Printer/Colour Printer/UPS

The Central Council ratified the decisions taken by the Executive Committee regarding the Computers, Printers purchase and also about the purchase of CCTV for the installation at places reflected in the minutes of the meeting of Executive Committee.

Agenda Item No. 49.24

Purchase of Digital Duplicator on DGS&D Rates under buy back offer reg.

The Central Council ratified the decisions of the Executive Committee and it granted the sanction of Rs. 2,14,535/- for purchase of new Duplicator Machine under buy back offer.

Agenda Item No. 49.25

Letter dated 17.03.2011 received from Association of Management of Homoeopathic Medical Colleges of Maharashtra regarding considering -

  1. The number of full time faculty for undergraduate BHMS Course,
  2. Proposal for 4 year BHMS curriculum And
  3. Revised pattern for non-teaching staff for only 25 Bedded hospitals.

The Central Council ratified the decision of Education Committee in the matter.

Agenda Item No. 49.26

Letter No. 6-1(11)2006 (CPP-1) dated 28.06.2012 received from University Grants Commission New Delhi reg. UGC (Institutions Deemed to be Universities ) First Amendment/Regulations, 2012

The Central Council ratified the decision of the Regulations Committee in the matter.

Agenda Item No. 49.27

Bill No.Advt/13 dated 27.04.2012 of Rs. 37,87,700/- received from Controller of Publications, Delhi.

The Central Council sanctioned Rs. 37,87,700/- regarding printing charges of Central Register in the Official Gazette.

Agenda Item No. 49.28

Bill No. 10 dated 18.04.2012 for Rs. 1,27,460/- received from publication Deptt.

The Central Council granted ex-post-facto sanction of Rs. 1,27,460/- which has been paid to Publication Department already.

Agenda Item No. 49.29

Payment of Rs. 1,67,213/- for purchase of Computer

The Central Council granted ex-post-facto sanction of Rs. 1,67,213/- which has been paid to M/s. K.S.Info Systems (P) Ltd., New Delhi for purchase of Computers etc.

Agenda Item No. 49.30

C.G.H.S. Contribution for the year 2012-13 reg

The Central Council granted sanction of Rs. 3,43,219/- for making a payment to C.G.H.S. in respect of Offices and Employees of this Council

Agenda Item No. 49.31

Payment above Rs. 50,000/-

The Central Council granted expost facto sanction to the following payments :-

1. M/s. Aim Consultants Pvt. Ltd. for providing Manpower during the month of March, 2012 1,22,927.00
2. M/s. Aim Consultants Pvt. Ltd. for providing Manpower during the month of April, 2012 1,78,893.00
3. M/s. Aim Consultants Pvt. Ltd. for providing Manpower during the month of May, 2012 1,81,799.00
4. M/s. Aim Consultants Pvt. Ltd. for providing Manpower during the month of June, 2012 2,01,049.00
5. Post Master, HPO, New Delhi in May, 2012 50,000.00
6. Post Master, HPO, New Delhi in June, 2012 1,00,000.00
7. Post Master, HPO, New Delhi in August, 2012 1,00,000.00
8. Gratuity to Smt. Raj Kaur, L.D.C. 3,77,883.00
9. Leave Salary to Smt. Raj Kaur, L.D.C. 2,29,020.00
10. Final G.P.F. payment to Smt. Raj Kaur, L.D.C. 7,09,501.00

Agenda Item No. 49.32

Development of Website of the Council and payments thereto-reg.

The Central Council granted the required sanction for release of payments as recommended by the Executive Committee for the Councils website to the concerned Company. The payment may be released within 7 days time.

Agenda Item No. 49.33

Ministry's letter No. R.13040/08/1997-HD (Pt.) dated 06.07.2012 regarding Creation of additional posts in CCH.

The Central Council noted the correspondence regarding additional posts in C.C.H. and approved the contents of the Councils letter dated August 1, 2012 (with enclosures).

Agenda Item No. 49.34

Bill No. Advt/III/IV/141/12 dated 27.07.2012 of Rs. 3,23,000/- received from Controller of Publication, Delhi.

The Central Council granted the sanction of Rs. 3,23,000/- regarding the printing charges of Publication of the list in the Gazette regarding removal of names from the Central Register.

Agenda Item No. 49.35

Minutes of the 153rd Meeting of the Executive Committee of Central Council of Homoeopathy held on 28.05.2012 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the decisions of Executive Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere.

Agenda Item No. 49.35

Minutes of the Meeting of the P.G. Education Committee of CCH held on 19.06.2012 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the decisions of the Registration Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere.

Agenda Item No. 48.36

Minutes of the 151st Meeting of the Executive Committee of the Central Council of Homoeopathy held on 31st January, 2012 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the decisions of P.G.Education Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere. However, the Council also decided to provide the information/documents asked by Dr.V.K.Khanna, Member in context of Agenda Item No. 5 of the said minutes.

Agenda Item No. 49.37

Minutes of the Meeting of the Education Committee of CCH held on 29.06.2012 at Bhubaneswar

The Central Council ratified the decisions of the Combined Meeting of Literature Review Committee & Editorial Board (of Academic Journal) which have not been discussed elsewhere.

Agenda Item No. 49.38

Minutes of the Meeting of the P.G. Education Committee of CCH held on 11.07.2012 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the decisions of P.G.Education Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere

Agenda Item No. 49.39

Minutes of the Meeting of the Regulation Committee of the Central Council of Homoeopathy held on 20th July, 2012 at New Delhi

The Central Council ratified the decisions of Regulation Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere

Agenda Item No. 49.40

Minutes of the Meeting of the Office Functioning Review Committee of CCH held on 30.07.2012 at New Delhi

The Central Council ratified the decisions of Office Functioning Review Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere

Agenda Item No. 49.41

Minutes of the Meeting of the Registration Committee of CCH held on 14.08.2012 at New Delhi

The Central Council ratified the decisions of Registration Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere.

Agenda Item No. 49.42

Minutes of the Meeting of the Finance Committee of CCH held on 17th August 2012 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the decisions of Finance Committee which have not discussed elsewhere except item No. 154.31. wherein the Executive Committee has shown its different opinion.

Agenda Item No. 49.43

Minutes of the 154th Meeting of the Executive Committee of Central Council of Homoeopathy held on 23rd August, 2012 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the decisions of Executive Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere subject to corrections in the spellings of "Mamber' as "Member" reflected in heading of item No.154.17 and also the date "23.09.2012" be corrected as "23.09.2011" in heading of item No.154.20 of said minutes.

Agenda Item No. 49.44

Minutes of the Rajbhasha Hindi Committee of Central Council of Homoeopathy held on 27th August, 2012 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the decisions of Rajbhasha Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere.

Agenda Item No. 49.45.1

Letter No.R.13040/118/2011-HD (Tech.) dated October, 2011 received from Department of AYUSH, Ministry of Health and Family Welfare Govt. of India, New Delhi regarding draft regulations for mandatory disclosure for Homoeopathy Colleges and for standards of Staff & other facilities .

The Central Council did not take up this matter in view of the Executive Committees decision of deferring it for next meeting thereof.

Agenda Item No. 49.45.2

Separation of post from Junior Hindi Translator-cum-H.C. to Junior Translator and Head Clerk. .

The Central Council ratified the decision of Executive Committee in the matter.

Agenda Item No. 49.45.3

Payment of Rs. 60,247/- to M/s. Kendriya Bhandar for purchase of Stationary.

The Central Council ratified the decision of Executive Committee in the matter.

Any other Item with the permission of the Chair

The Central resolved as under:-

1.

The Central Council adopted the following resolutions:-

(a) "The Central Council of Homoeopathy in its 48th meeting held on 21st March, 2012 has approved the draft formulated by Committee on Excellence in Homoeopathic Education "BHMS Homoeopathy Degree Course, CURRICULUM, 2012, comprising of more than 300 pages. It consists of particulars of topics to be covered in each of the subject of BHMS Course. Distribution of topics in terms of knowledge, skill, attitude, the must know areas in the syllabus, evaluation system which is very useful reference in teaching-learning process. While appreciating the efforts of the members of the committee on Excellence in Homoeopathic Education, it is now resolved in the 49th meeting of the CCH, held on 28th August, 2012, to publish the same in the form of a reference book, as early as possible as priced publication of the Council for the guidance of the faculty members.

Dr.Ramji Singh, President, CCH, Dr.Arun Bhasame, Vice-President, CCH and Dr.Arvind Kothe Chairman, Committee on Excellence in Homoeopathic Education be designated as the board of editors and they be authorized to undertake necessary editing".

Proposed by: Dr.M.K.Sahani
Seconded by: Dr.Kulwant Singh


(b) (a) "It is resolved to conduct 3 days workshop on Homoeopathic Medical Education Technology, Module I, and Module II for the teaching staff of Homoeopathic Colleges in India, to develop and augment their teaching skill as well to bring reasonable uniformity in the patient management as a part of their regular activity"
Dr.Ramji Singh, President, CCH, Dr.Arun Bhasame, Vice-President, CCH and Dr.Arvind Kothe Chairman, Committee on Excellence in Homoeopathic Education be designated as the board of editors and they be authorized to undertake necessary editing".

Proposed by: Dr.V.K.Khanna
Seconded by: Dr.V.V.Nagaraja Rao


(c)" It is also resolved to encourage Homoeopathic Colleges to organize workshops on Homoeopathic Medical Education Technology in their Institutes in collaboration with the CCH. The CCH shall make the payments of TA & DA of Resources persons. The workshop shall be conducted as per the guidelines formulated by the CCH, and the detailed report including Pre and Post assessment of the participants be forwarded to CCH".

Proposed by: Dr.B.N.Prakash
Seconded by: Dr. N.V.Sugathan

2.

The Central Council decided to postpone the inspection of Dr.A.C.Homoeopthic Medical College and Hospital, Bhubaneshwar for the time being considering the letter dated 28.8.12 signed by Dr.P.K.Behera, Incharge Principal of this College.

3.

The Central Council considered letter dated 8.8.2012 of Dr.Jose Issac, Member and it decided to impress upon the Kerala University of Health Sciences in the matter.

4. The Central Council asked the Secretary, CCH to call a meeting of Liaison Committee during September, 2012.
5. The Central Council decided to request Dr.C.Nayak, Member, to look into Establishment of New Medical College (Opening of New or Higher Course of Study or Training and Increase of Admission Capacity by a Medical College) Regulations, 2011and suggest amendments therein.
6. 1. The Central Council decided to remind the Sub-Committee constituted earlier for finalization of amendments in Standard Information Forms.
7. 1. The Central Council decided to request its members for their original contributions by sending articles for the proposed journal of C.C.H..

Meeting ended with a vote of thanks to the Chair

Sd/-
(Dr.Ramjee Singh)
President

Sd/-
(Dr.Lalit Verma)
Secretary
31.8.2012

MINUTES OF THE 48th MEETING OF THE CENTRAL COUNCIL OF HOMOEOPATHY HELD ON 21th MARCH, 2012 AT NEW DELHI

Present

1 Dr.Ramjee Singh President
2 Dr.Arun Bhasme Vice-President
3 Dr.Mahendra Singh Member
4 Dr.M.K.Sahani
5 Dr.Kulwant Singh
6 Dr.Narayan Debnath
7 Dr.A.P.Verma
8 Dr.Vimal Kumar Dhawan
9 Dr.B.Sohan Singh
10 Dr.Ramesh Dogra
11 Dr.Pankaj Kumar Sharma
12 Dr.Naresh Arora
13 Dr.M.R.Srivatsan
14 Dr.S.P.Singh
15 Dr.K.K.Juneja
16 Dr.Saidul Islam
17 Dr.V.K.Khanna
18 Dr.B.N.Prakash
19 Dr.B.N.Singh
20 Dr.L.M.Khan
21 Dr.C.Nayak
22 Dr.S.M.Desarda
23 Dr.Jose Issac
24 Dr.Veerabramcharya
25 Dr.V.V.Nagaraja Rao
26 Dr.V.R.Kawishwar
27 Dr.Bhosale R.N.
28 Dr.Amiya Goswami
29 Dr.Teli Hotu Comdir
30 Dr.A.B.Jadhav
31 Dr.Mohammad Zakharia
32 Dr.Heenaben Kartikey Raval
33 Dr.P.S.Ranu
34 Dr.N.V.Sugathan
35 Dr.P.K.Sudhir
36 Dr.Arvind Kothe
37 Dr.Ramendra Laskar
38 Dr.L.K.Nanda
39 Dr.G.Nirmal
40 Dr.J.K.Patel
41 Dr.Girish S.Patel
42 Dr.Ghanshyam D.Raval
43 Dr.K.K.Kar
44 Dr.A.U.Ramakrishan Secretary

Not Present

1 Dr.K.V.John
2 Dr.K.P.Mazumdar
3 Dr.Ramkrishna Ghosh Mondal
4 Dr.P.Banerjee
5 Dr. Kanekar Rajendra Ramesh
6 Dr.S. Vidyaprakash
7 Dr.G.P.Hahnemann
8 Dr.Sibendranath Sinha

The members namely, Dr.S.Vidyaprakash, Dr.P.Banerjee and Dr.G.P.Hahnemman informed of their respective inability to attend this meeting and they were granted leave of absence.

The Secretary informed about the passing away of the first nominated Vice-President and first elected President, Dr.Jugal Kishore, and first elected Vice-President Dr.Diwan Harish Chand (who has been a sitting member of CCH), and former member Dr.R.P.Dubey and also about the passing away of Sh. Khemajibhai Patel f/o Dr.J.K.Patel, Member. The Secretary also informed the contribution of Dr.Jugal Kishore and Dr.Diwan Harish in Central Council of Homoeopathy in particular and in Homoeopathy in general. The President, Vice-President, Members and Officials present in the meeting stood in silence for one minute to pay their homage to the departed souls. It was decided to send the message of condolence to all the bereaved families.

Agenda Item No. 48.1

(1). Confirmation of the minutes of the 47th meeting of the Central Council of Homoeopathy held on 21st October, 2011 at New Delhi.

2). Letter dated 24.11.2011 from Dr. C. Nayak, Member.

The Central Council confirmed the minutes of its last meeting held at New Delhi on 21.10.2011 as circulated, after taking into consideration the letter dated 24.11.2011 of Dr.C.Nayak, Member. Dr.B.N.Prakash, Member gave a note of dissent which may be seen enclosed.

Agenda Item No. 48.2

Action taken on the minutes of the 47th meeting of the Central Council of Homoeopathy held on 21st October, 2011 at New Delhi.

The Central Council noted Action Taken Report in respect of the minutes of its last meeting

Agenda Item No. 48.3

Ministry's letter No. V.27013/2/2011-EP (IM-2) dated 21.11.2011 regarding inclusion of the names of Colleges along with names of University in 2nd Schedule of IMCC Act, 19701

The Central Council decided to wait for the reply of C.C.I.M. in the matter. A reminder may be sent to C.C.I.M

Agenda Item No. 48.4

Approval of P.G. Guides/Examiners for M.D. (Hom.) Courses in respect of different universities.

The Central Council approved/ratified the panel of Examiners/Guides for M.D.(Hom.) courses in respect of MUHS Nashik, Dr.N.T.R.University of Health Sciences, Vijayawada and Sardar Patel University.

The Council also decided that no name in the panel will be added unless it has been forwarded in the panel by the University concerned and the person being approved in the panel fulfill all the prescribed qualification and experience.

Agenda Item No. 48.5

Workshop held by CCH during October, 2011 to March 2012.

The Central Council noted the report on the workshop held on 30th November, 2011.

Agenda Item No. 48.6

Ministry's letter No. R.13040/13/2006-HD dated 5.08.2011 regarding External M.D. (Hom.) Degree Courses.

The Central Council ratified the decision of P.G.Education Committee which has already been forwarded to Department of AYUSH, Govt. of India

 

Agenda Item No. 48.7

Amendment in Establishment of New Medical College (Opening of New or Higher Courses of Study or Training and increase of Admission Capacity by a Medical College) Regulations, 2011.

The Central Council approved the amendments proposed by Regulations Committee in the Establishment of New Medical College (Opening of New or Higher Courses of Study or Training and Increase of Admission Capacity by a Medical College) Regulations, 2011 and these amendments may be forwarded to Central Govt. for sanction."

However, the Education Committee may also look into the need of teaching faculty separately for I-BHMS Course, 2nd BHMS Course, 3rd BHMS Course and so on keeping in view the requirement of such teaching faculty in a new college which will be inspected every year by the Central Council.

Agenda Item No. 48.8

The Central Council decided to remove the names of practitioners from the Central Register on the basis of letter dated 15.2.2012 of Homoeopathy Medicine Board, U.P. . However, the Council again recommended for amendment in Registration Regulations by omission of regulation 9 from the said Regulations.

Agenda Item No. 48.9

Restoration of names in Central Register of Homeopathy.

The Central Council ratified the decision of Registration Committee for restoration of the names in the Central Register.

Agenda Item No. 48.10

Approval of Recruitment Rules of various posts recommended by C.C.H.

The Central Council ratified the decision of Executive Committee in the matter for which the Central Government must be persuaded to allow the sanction of additional posts.

Agenda Item No. 48.11

  1. Judgment delivered by the Hon'ble CAT in Original Application No. 3522 of 2010.
  2. Application dated 09.01.2012 of Shri H.D. Rikhadi, Asstt.Secretary (Admn. & Regn.) regarding retirement on Superannuation basis.

The Central Council ratified the decision of Executive Committee in the matter.

Agenda Item No. 48.12

Request received under section 12A of Homoeopathy Central Council Act for increase in the intake capacity.

The Central Council sanctioned Rs. 88,500 for making the payment in favour of the Controller of Publication, Govt. of India, Delhi.

Agenda Item No. 48.13

Bill No. 169 dated 23.12.2011, for Rs. 1,81,090/- received from Publication Deptt. Civil Lines, New Delhi.

The Central Council sanctioned Rs. 1,81,090 for making the payment in favour of the Controller of Publication, Govt. of India, Delhi.

Agenda Item No. 48.14

Compliance Reports received from some Homoeopathic Medical Colleges in view of shortfalls/Observation Reports as per following letters:-

  1. No. YPSM/CCH/2011-12/2894, dated 28.08.2011
  2. No. JJMHMC/2011-2012/Comp. Report/212, dated 12.08.2011.
  3. No. TSHMC/12/230/2011, dated 12.09.2011
  4. No. 863/C3/11/GHMC, dated 31.08.2011.
  5. No. AHMC/RG/11/09/795, dated 13.09.2011
  6. Ref. No. 370A/2011, dated 05.09.2011
  7. Ref. No. DHMC/RTN/732 dated 23.09.2011.

The Central Council ratified the decisions of Executive Committee.

Agenda Item No. 48.15

  1. Ministry's letter No. R. 12014/04/2010-EP dated 20.01.2011 regarding application for grant of permission of the Central Govt. to start a new Shree B.G. Garaiya Homoeopathic Medical College at Rajkot by Director, Gyanjyot Education Trust, Rajkot with annual intake capacity of 100 seats in BHMS Course, under Section 12A of the HCC Act.
  2. Ministry letter No. R. 13040/96/2011-HD (Tech) dated 14.11.2011 regarding Court Case Special Civil Application No. 14499/2011, Gyan Jyoy Education Trust V/s Govt. of India.

The Central Council ratified the decisions of Executive Committee..

Agenda Item No. 48.16

Letter No. BHMS/Admn/2012/235 dated 14.01.2012 regarding Application for grant for holding " National Workshop on Thesis/Dissertation writing" organized by Bakson Homoeopathic Medical College & Hospital Greater Noida in collaboration with Central Council of Homoeopathy- regarding

The Central Council ratified the decision of Executive Committee.

Agenda Item No. 48.17

Payment above Rs. 50,000/-

The Central Council granted expost-facto sanction to the following payments :-

1. Post Master, H.P.O., New Delhi
for Postage Stamps in Franking Machine
1,00,000/-
2. (a) Wage Expenditure to M/s. Bedi & Bedi for hiring Manpower 83,983/-
3. ( b) Wage Expenditure to M/s. Bedi & Bedi for hiring Manpower 86,783/-
4. Adjustment of D.A.V.P. Expenses 87,391/-
5. Gratuity to Shri Lekh Raj, Ex. G.O. 3,02,973/-
6. Wage Expenditure to M/s. AIM Consultants 58,166/-
7. LTC Expenditure Adjustment in respect of
Dr. Lalit Verma, Registrar-cum-Secretary
55,932/-
8. (i) Leave encashment to Sh.H.D. Rikhadi, Ex. Asstt.Secy.(A&R)
(ii) Gratuity to Sh. H.D. Rikhadi, Ex. Asstt.Secy.(A&R)
4,79,690/-
7,91,489/-
9. Stationery Expenses to M/s. Kendriya Bhandar 51,333/-

 

Agenda Item No. 48.18

Ministry's letter No. R.13040/10/2011-HD (Tech.) (Part) dated 27.05.2011 regarding poor admission in BHMS Degree Course at National Level Involvement of CBSE in BHMS admission.

The Central Council discussed the matter in great details and decided that the members may send their comments in writing to Secretary, C.C.H. within a period of 15 days. All the comments received alongwith this matter may be placed before Education Committee which may draft the procedure for conducting entrance test through CBSE for admission in BHMS Degree Course at All India Level. The office might have collected some information from CBSE and MCI if the same is available that may also be placed before Education Committee.

Agenda Item No. 48.19

Letter No. A.M.G.IV/S.A.R./C.C.H./2011-12/10-14/241 dated 27th Oct., 2011 received from Deputy Director, (A.M.G.-IV) Office of the Director General of Audit (Central Expenditure) New Delhi regarding Audit Report on account of CCH for the year 2010-11.

The Central Council noted the Audit Report and also the reply sent with prior approval of the Executive Committee.

Agenda Item No. 48.20

Selection of Asstt. Secretary (Admn. & Regn.), CCH.

The Central Council noted the promotion of Shri Y.D.Vats on the post of Assistant Secretary (Admn. & Regn.) in C.C.H.

Agenda Item No. 48.21

Sanction of Outsourcing Personnels from M/S AIM Consultant PVT. LTD

(1) Bill / Invoice No. CCH/02/02/2012/110 dated 3.02.2012 regarding payment of Rs.1,13,683/- for the month of January , 2012.
(2) Letter No. AIM/CCH/01/2012/133 dated Nil regarding relaxation of Penalty @ Rs. 200/- per day for abstainers.
(3) Letter No. AIM/CCH/01/2012/134/ dated 27.01.2012 regarding revised the "Minimum wages "by 3.67% of the approved base rates.

The Central Council sanctioned Rs. 1,07,828/- only for making payment to M/s. AIM Consultant Pvt. Limited after restricting its bill dated 3.2.2012. The Council also allowed revision in the minimum wages as proposed in the letter dated 27.1.2012 of above named agency.

Agenda Item No. 48.22.

Amendments in Central Council of Homoeopathy (General) Regulations.

The Central Council discussed the matter and it authorized the President to forward the amendments in the General Regulations to the Ministry with justifications after having a re-look into the draft.

Agenda Item No. 48.23

Amendment in the Form 'A' in Registration Regulations.

The Central Council agreed with the decision of Registration Committee for an amendment in Form 'A' by making a provision at a suitable place for submitting an attested copy of any document confirming the applicants residential address which may be Indian Election Commissions Identity Card or the Passport or the Driving Licence and further may be Ration Card, Adhar Card, Telephone Bill of MTNL/BSNL, Electricity Bill or ID card issued by State Board/Council of Homoeopathy.

Agenda Item No. 48.24

Amendments proposed in Homoeopathy Central Council (Inspectors and Visitors) Regulation, 1982.

The Central Council discussed the matter and it authorized the President to forward the amendments in the Homoeopathy Central Council (Inspectors and Visitors) Regulations, 1982 to the Ministry after having a re-look into the draft from grammatical point of view and if he feels any need he may consult any of the C.C.H. Members in that regard.

The Central Council also decided to consult Medical Council of India as to how it is outsourcing the ticketing etc. for the purposes of inspections.

Agenda Item No. 48.25

  1. Consideration of inspection reports of Homoeopathic Medical Colleges in the State of Assam, Andhra Pradesh, Bihar, Chandigarh, Delhi, Gujarat, Goa, Haryana, Himachal Pradesh, Jharkhand, Kerala, Karnataka, Madhya Pradesh, Maharashtra, Orissa, Punjab, Rajasthan, Tamil Nadu, Uttar Pradesh, and West Bengal.
  2. Consideration of reports of inspection of Homoeopathic Medical College under Section 12A of HCC Act. (Under Court Case)

The Central Council ratified the decisions of Executive Committee in the matter.

Agenda Item No. 48.26

  1. Amendments of Homoeopathy (Minimum Standards of Education) Regulations correspondence with Ministry
  2. Ministry's Letter No. R. 14030/29/2005-HE(Tech.) dated 22.07.2011 regarding amendment in Homoeopathy (Minimum Standards of Education)Regulations

The Central Council discussed the matter in great depth and it decided to authorize the President to have consultations with CCH members to deal with the matter.

Agenda Item No. 48.27

  1. Ministry's Letter No. R.13015/14/2009-HD-(CCH) dated 11-11-2011 regarding Grant of P.G. Allowance and Annual Allowance to Technical Officers in C.C.H.
  2. D.O.Letter No.R.13015/14/2009-EP(H) CCH dated 04.01.2012 from Shri V.S. Gaur, Joint Secretary, Deptt. of AYUSH, G.O.I.

The Central Council ratified the decisions taken by the Executive Committee in the matter from time to time. The Central Council did not found any justification in recovery from the concerned officials.

Agenda Item No. 48.28

Letter dated 14.01.2012 regarding Participation of CCH in LIGA Congress of LMHI.

The Central Council noted its active participation in LIGA Congress of LMHI at Delhi, and it agreed with the proposal of Dr.M.K.Sahani, Member, C.C.H.

Agenda Item No. 48.29

JJ/DEL/Dec-11/1002 dated December 15, 2011 received from Advocate Sh. Shilendra Babbar in r/o SLP No. 9872/2010 (CC No.4273/10) Smt. Preet Chattani V/s Rastrasant Tukdoji Maharaj in Supreme Court of India

The Central Council sanctioned Rs. 62,700/- for payment to Advocate Sh.Shailender Babbar as recommended by the Executive Committee.

Agenda Item No. 48.30

Letter dated 12.01.2012 received from Karnataka State Govt. Teachers Welfare Association, Bangalore.

The Central Council of Homoeopathy accepted the proposal for reflecting the same in amendments to Homoeopathy (Minimum Standards of Education) Regulations..

Agenda Item No. 48.31

The Central Council considered the matter and decided that the competent authorities of all the State Govts. may be informed the provisions of Section 15(4) of Homoeopathy Central Council Act, 1973 for taking necessary action in respect of those persons who are practicing Homoeopathy in violation of the provisions of Section 15 (1), (2) and (3) of the said Act. A copy of such a letter may also be circulated amongst all the State Boards/Councils of Homoeopathy.

Agenda Item No. 48.32

The Central Council ratified the decisions of the Committee concerning Excellence in Education in Homoeopathy which have not been discussed elsewhere..

The Central Council ratified the decisions of the Committee concerning Excellence in Education in Homoeopathy which have not been discussed elsewhere.

Agenda Item No. 48.33

Minutes of the Meeting of the P.G. Education Committee of the Central Council of Homoeopathy held on 3rd January, 2012 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the decisions of the P.G.Education Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere.

Agenda Item No. 48.34

Minutes of the Meeting of the Regulations Committee of the Central Council of Homoeopathy held on 9.01.2012 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the decisions of the Regulations Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere.

Agenda Item No. 48.35

Minutes of the Meeting of the Registration Committee of the Central Council of Homoeopathy held on 25.01.2012 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the decision of Executive Committee in the matter.

Agenda Item No. 47.35

Letter dated 25.03.2011 received from Dr. A.P. Verma regarding Slogan.

The Central Council ratified the decisions of the Registration Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere.

Agenda Item No. 48.36

Minutes of the 151st Meeting of the Executive Committee of the Central Council of Homoeopathy held on 31st January, 2012 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the decisions of the Executive Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere.

Agenda Item No. 48.37

Minutes of the Combined Meeting of Literature Review Committee & Editorial Board (of Academic Journal) held on 13th February, 2012 at New Delhi

The Central Council ratified the decisions of the Combined Meeting of Literature Review Committee & Editorial Board (of Academic Journal) which have not been discussed elsewhere.

Agenda Item No. 48.38

Minutes of the meeting of Office Review Committee to be held on 22nd February, 2012 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the decisions of the Office Review Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere.

Agenda Item No. 48.39

Minutes of the meeting of Committee on Excellence in Education in Homoeopathy to be held on 5th March, 2012 at New Delhi

The Central Council ratified the decisions of the Excellence in Education in Homoeopathy which have not been discussed elsewhere. The Central Council also approved the draft "Homoeopathy Degree Course CURRICULUM-2012" as placed in the meeting by Dr.Arvind Kothe, Chairman of said Committee.

Agenda Item No. 48.40

Minutes of the P.G. Education Committee of CCH to held on 13th March, 2012 at New Delhi.

The Central Council decided that the draft P.G. Degree Course in Forensic Medicine and Toxicology may be forwarded to Dr.Arun Jadhav, Member for a review in consultation with various experts available in the city of Pune and in Bharati Vidhyapeeth Deemed University who may be consulted by him, and Dr.Jadhav may submit his draft (with comments in the matter) within a period of 15 days to the Secretary, Central Council

The Council decided further that the draft in Physiology & Biochemistry in respect of P.G.Degree Course may be sent to Dr.L.M.Khan, Member who may review it in consultation with experts available in National Institute of Homoeopathy and he may submit the draft (with comments in the matter) with a period of 15 days to the Secretary, Central Council.

The Council further decided that Dr.C.Nayak may fix up the date in consultation with Secretary, CCH and he may come to C.C.H. Office to look into the errors in the draft courses of Community Medicine, and Pathology for rectifying numerical/grammatical errors

It was decided that the draft in Anatomy in respect of P.G.Degree Course may be sent to Dr.V.R.Kavishwar who may review it in consultation with various experts available in the subject (to him) and he may submit his draft (with comments in the matter) within a period of 15 days to the Secretary, Central Council.

The Central Council approved the draft P.G.Courses in new subjects as recommended by P.G.Education Committee provided that the comments received from above named members will be considered by Chairman P.G.Education Committee & President to finalise the said draft courses for taking further action as per Homoeopthy Central Council Act.

The Central Council also ratified the decisions of the P.G.Education Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere and also subject to above decisions.

Agenda Item No. 48.41

Minutes of the 152nd Meeting of the Executive Committee of the Central Council of Homoeopathy to be held on 14th March, 2012 at New Delhi

The Central Council ratified the decisions of the Executive Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere subject to addition of name of Sinha Homoeopathic Medical College (letter dated 27.2.2012) amongst other colleges in respect of item discussed at No. 1 under the heading of "Any Other Item with the Permission of the Chair", and also approved the D.A.C.P. Scheme proposed by the Executive Committee for Officers appointed on medical qualification basis, engagement of additional 6 persons through outsource agency. The Central Council sanctioned Rs. 1,11,466/- for payment to M/s. Gupta Photostat and further for putting an amount of Rs. 10,73,330/- more during current financial year in the Pension Fund Account from its main account (through internal resources).

In respect of Agenda Item No. 152.18.23.7 & 152.18.23.8 reflected in the said minutes must be acted upon without any delay for sending the required information to Central Govt. The Central Council also approved the decision of Executive Committee in respect of Ministry's letter No. R.13040/85/2011 HD (Tech.) dated 6.3.2012. It also approved change in re-designating First Appellate Authority & PIOs under RTI Act in respect of Central Council of Homoeopathy.

Dr.S.M.Desarda pointed out that Ministry's letter No.Z.28015/23/2012-P&C dated 13.3.12 for deployment of C.C.H. staff for election duty was also discussed in Executive Committee on 14.3.12 and it was decided that the staff and officials are already short in the Council and further the are busy in the Councils work and the Council can not depute them for the said work as mentioned in the Ministry's letter, but some how this has been missed in the said minutes. The President decided to bring this decision in the minutes of this meeting. The Council noted that a reply has been sent to Ministry as per said decision on 14.3.2012.

Agenda Item No. 48.42

Minutes of the Education Committee of CCH to be held on 20th March, 2012 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the decisions of the Education Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere.

Agenda Item No. 48.43

Minutes of the Finance Committee of CCH to be held on 20th March, 2012 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the decisions of the Finance Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere subject to increase in inspection fee will be applicable after every three years as per rates/policy recommended by Finance Committee.

Agenda Item No. 48.44

Refurnishing of the CCH Office through NPCC.

The Central Council ratified the decision taken by the Executive Committee in the matter.

Agenda Item No. 48.45

Letter No. AC11/(1)60583/2011 dated 26.12.2011 received from the Tamil Nadu Dr. M.G.R. Medical University, Chennai regarding modifications made in the Curriculum/Regulations in the Medical Degree Course- consent requested regarding.

The Central Council ratified the decisions taken by the P.G.Education Committee and Education Committee in the matter..

Agenda Item No. 48.46

  1. Ministry's Letter No. R.13040/40/2008-HD (Tech.) dated 29.04.2008 regarding recognition of medical qualification Under Section 14 (2) of H.C.C. Act, 1973.
  2. Ministry's Letter No. R.13040/40/2008-HD (Tech.) dated 3.02.2011 regarding recognition of medical qualification Under Section 14 (2) of H.C.C. Act, 1973

The Central Council decided to recommend inclusion of BHMS qualification awarded by Poorbanchal University, Nepal in Third Schedule of Homoeopathy Central Council Act subject to:

  1. that the Nepal Health Professional Council grants recognition to BHMS Degree or an equivalent qualification included in Second Schedule to Homoeopathy Central Council Act on reciprocal basis, and
  2. that Information is furnished by the Poorbanchal University as per decision of Executive Committee taken on 14.3.2012.

Agenda Item No. 48.47

Candidates enrolled in P.G. Centers and their affiliating Universities.

The Central Council agreed with the recommendation of its P.G.Education Committee to ask all the Universities and Homoeopathic Colleges conducting M.D.(Hom.) Courses to strictly follow the provisions of Homoeopathy (Post Graduate Degree Course) Regulations as amended from time to time, and also decided to write to each University conducting M.D.(Hom.) courses to make available its Ordinances/Regulations laid down for M.D.(Hom.) Courses for examining them as to whether they are in conformity to P.G.Regulations of C.C.H. The Council also agreed with a P.G.Committee recommendations for arranging a work shop for the Guides by the C.C.H. on "Dissertation Writing" , and another workshop for the Principals of recognized P.G.Centres to sensitize them about the amendments in P.G.Regulations which are under notification in Govt. Press.

Supplementary Agenda

Agenda Item No. 48.48.1

Payment above Rs. 50,000/-

The Central Council granted ex-post-facto sanction Rs. 53,437/- only which has been paid to M/s.Kansil Printers for printing of C.C.H. Diary.

Agenda Item No. 48.48.2

Request received under Section 12 A of Homoeopathy Central Council Act for opening of New/Higher Courses.

The Central Council noted the decisions taken by the Executive Committee in the matter.

Agenda Item No. 48.48.3

Letter received from Dr.S.P.Singh, Member, CCH regarding constitution of National Board of Examination in Homoeopathy.

The Central Council ratified the decision taken by the Education Committee in the matter and it decided that the President of the Council may forward to the Secretary in Department of AYUSH, Govt. of India for an action on priority basis.

Agenda Item No. 48.48.4.1

Minutes of the meeting of the Editorial Board of Indian Journal of Homoeopathic Education and Research (I.J.H.E.R.) held on 15th March, 2012 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the minutes of the Editorial Board of IJHER which met on 15.3.2012. The Central Council decided that sitting allowance may be paid to be members of Editorial Board including the meeting held on 15.3.2012.

Agenda Item No. 48.48.4.2

Letter dated NIL received from Dr.S.Das Gupta, from Jamshedpur regarding complaint in respect of Govt.Godda Homoeopathic Medical College & Hospital, Godda, Jamshedpur.

The Central Council discussed the matter and resolved as under:-

"Matter related to Godda Homoeopathic Medical College, Godda, Jharkhand was discussed in details. It was observed from the Inspection report of the College that the term for the ten teachers were not renewed as such they were terminated and the certificate of eight remaining teachers were found to be false and fabricated and their services are now terminated, as such at present there are no teaching faculty. Recently State Government has deputed ten medical officers of the health department as teacher, but they do not have teaching experience. The Vonoba Bhave University, Hazaribagh has granted affiliation to the college for session 2004-06 with retrospective effect. No new admissions are taken in the session 2010-11 onward.

 

Under the mentioned fact it is resolved that Central Council of Homoeopathy should recommend to take action by not allowing further admission in the Godda Homoeopathic Medical College. Further it was resolved that Council should write to the Vinoba Bhave University for suspending the affiliation. It was also resolved that considering the future career of the admitted students, State Government should take initiative to transfer them to other Homoeopathic Medical College".

Proposed by : Dr.Sahidul Islam
Seconded by: Dr.Mahendra Singh

Any other Item with the permission of the Chair

The Central Council ratified the decisions of Registration Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere in these minutes.

Any other Item with the permission of the Chair

The Central resolved as under:-

1. It is resolved that Dr.Arun Bhasme, Vice-President, C.C.H. will be the Co-Editor for the proposed Indian Journal of Homoeopathic Education and Research (IJHER).

Proposed by: Dr.M.K.Sahani
Seconded by Dr.Ravi N.Bhosale

2.

The Central Resolved as under:-

In view of the decision of the Council to use outsource persons for the heavy load of continually increasing works of the Council, the President is empowered to spend total (two lacs) more in addition to the last decision of Rs. 1 lakh expenditure by the President on all new work process"

Proposed by :Dr.M.K.Sahani.
Seconded by: Dr.Mahendra Singh

3.

The Central Council resolved as under:-

"The General Body considered the matter of travel of members of the CCH for the attending meetings as well as Visitation of College. It was resolved that all members be allowed to travel by any airlines as per availability".

Proposed by: Dr.S.M.Desarda
Seconded by: Dr.M.K.Sahani.

  The Central Council considered bill/invoice No. CCHG/03/03/2012 /126 dated 5.3.2012 of M/s.AIM Consultants Pvt.Ltd.and it decided to sanction Rs. 1,23,897/- only for the month of Feb.2012.
  The written request of Dr.P.S.Ranu & Dr. V.K.Dhwan, Members has been discussed and the Council decided that students undergoing internship training in BHMS degree course need to be granted provisional registration by State Boards/Council as per Section 25 A of Homoeopathy Central Council Act irrespective of the fact whether qualification to be awarded to them is in Second Schedule or not.
  The Central Council allowed the TA claim of Dr.Ajay Kumar Sharma for undertaking inspection of Chandrakant Hari Keluskar, Homoeopathic Medical College, Alibagh on 14-15 December, 2011.

Meeting ended with a vote of thanks to the Chair.

Sd/-
(Dr.Ramjee Singh)
President

Sd/-
(Dr.Lalit Verma)
Secretary

MINUTES OF THE 47th MEETING OF THE CENTRAL COUNCIL OF HOMOEOPATHY HELD ON 21th OCTOBER, 2011 AT NEW DELHI

Present

1 Dr.Ramjee Singh President
2 Dr.Arun Bhasme Vice-President
3 Dr.S. Vidya Prakash Member
4 Dr.Mahendra Sing
5 Dr.M.K.Sahani
6 Dr.Kulwant Singh
7 Dr.G.P.Hahnemann
8 Dr.Narayan Debnath
9 Dr.A.P.Verma
10 Dr.Vimal Kumar Dhawan
11 Dr.B.Sohan Singh
12 Dr.Ramesh Dogra
13 Dr.Pankaj Kumar Sharma
14 Dr.Naresh Arora
15 Dr.M.R.Srivatsan
16 Dr.S.P.Singh
17 Dr.K.K.Juneja
18 Dr.Saidul Islam
19 Dr.Sibendranath Sinha
20 Dr.V.K.Khanna
21 Dr.B.N.Prakash
22 Dr.K.K.Kar
23 Dr.B.N.Singh
24 Dr.L.M.Khan
25 Dr.C.Nayak
26 Dr.S.M.Desarda
27 Dr.Jose Issac
28 Dr.Pankaj C.Dave
29 Dr.Veerabramcharya
30 Dr.V.V.Nagaraja Rao
31 Dr.V.R.Kawishwar
32 Dr.Bhosale R.N.
33 Dr.Amiya Goswami
34 Dr.Teli Hotu Comdir
35 Dr.A.B.Jadhav
36 Dr.Mohammad Zakharia
37 Dr.Heenaben Kartikey Raval
38 Dr.P.S.Ranu
39 Dr.N.V.Sugathan
40 Dr.P.K.Sudhir
41 Dr.Arvind Kothe
42 Dr.Ramendra Laskar
43 Dr.L.K.Nanda
Dr.Lalit Verma Secretary

Not Present

1 Dr.G.Nirmal
2 Dr.J.K.Patel
3 Dr.Diwan Harish Chand
4 Dr.K.V.John
5 Dr.A.U.Ramakrishan
6 Dr.Girish S.Patel
7 Dr.Ghanshyam D.Raval
8 Dr.K.P.Mazumdar
9 Dr.Ramkrishna Ghosh Mondal
10 Dr.Shailendra Tripathy
11 Dr.P.Banerjee
12 Dr. Kanekar Rajendra Ramesh

Dr.P.Banerjee, Dr.G.Nirmal, Dr.Girish Patel and Dr.Diwan Harish Chand informed their inability to attend the meeting.

The President extended a warm welcome to all the members and officials of the Council in the 47th Meeting and expressed his gratitudes to the ceased members namely Dr.U.S.Choudhary and Dr.G.B.Panigrahi. The President greeted the new Member Dr.Kulwant Singh, and also the re-elected members namely, Dr.M.K.Sahani and Dr.P.K.Sudhir. He also informed about Dr.N.V.Sugathan joining the Council again under Court Order. The President briefed the Council about all out efforts of him to co-ordinate with Department of AYUSH, Govt. of India Authorities as well as about the meetings with the Hon ble Health Ministers of Delhi and Odisha for holding discussions about the problems concerning the States being governed by them. He also highlighted the meeting with the Vice-Chancellor of B.A.Bihar University, Muzaffarpur. He briefly informed about the three workshops held on R.F.D., Teaching Module-I and on Forensic Medicine under the aegis of Central Council of Homoeopathy. A copy of the Address of President, CCH is placed as Annexure-A to these minutes.

Agenda Item No. 47.1

(A). Confirmation of the Minutes of the 46th Meeting of the Central Council of Homoeopathy held on 25.03.2011 at New Delhi.

(B). Corrigendum to Minutes of the 46th Meeting of the CCH held on 25th March, 2011 at New Delhi.

The Central Council confirmed the minutes of its last meeting including the corrigendum.

Agenda Item No. 47.2

Action Taken of the Minutes of the 46th Meeting of the Central Council of Homoeopathy held on 25.03.2011 at New Delhi

The Central Council noted the Action Taken Report in respect of the minutes of its last meeting.

Agenda Item No. 47.3

Annual Report of Central Council of Homoeopathy of the year 2010-11

The Central Council approved the draft Annual Report subject to the following modifications

(in english version which may be accordingly carried out in hindi too)

  • Other activities may be reflected below the workshops;
  • In para No. 2 under the heading of Other Activities the spellings of Vigilcnce may be corrected as Vigilance ;
  • At point No. 2 under the workshop the para may be reworded as A workshop of two days duration was organized by CCH for Teachers of Homoeopathic Medical Colleges on Pathology subject on 23rd and 24th September, 2010.

Agenda Item No. 47.4

Annual Accounts of CCH for the year 2010-11

The Central Council approved the Annual Accounts of the year 2010-11 as forwarded to D.G.A.C.R. and to Department of AYUSH, Govt. of India.

Agenda Item No. 47.5

R.E. & B.E. for 2011-12 and 2012-13 respectively under Plan & Non-Plan of Central Council of Homoeopathy.

The Central Council approved the RE and BE as recommended by the Finance Committee and Executive Committee.

Agenda Item No. 47.6

Amendments in Homoeopathy (Minimum Standards of Education) Regulation Correspondence with Ministry.

&

Agenda Item No. 47.7

Amendments in Homoeopathy (Minimum Standards of Education) Regulations.

The Central Council adopted the following resolution and also recommended the further amendments in the Homoeopathy (Minimum Standards of Education) as enclosed at Annexure-B. Central Council of Homoeopathy in its meeting of 21st October, 2011 discussed the matter related to Minimum Standards of Education regulation in details and observed addition and alteration in it. Minimum Standards of Education was finally approved and the house authorized the president to look into the minute details and if necessary he may make necessary correction in consultation with some of the members whom he feel deem fit for it .

Proposed by: Dr.Mahendra Singh
Second by: Dr.M.K.Sahanih
Dr.Anurudh Verma

The Central Council debated for a pretty long time as to whether in view of the remarks of Sh.V.S.Gaur, Joint Secretary, Department of AYUSH, Govt. of India during discussions in a meeting held in the Ministry with the President, CCH that the regulations may be amended with the intention to give some inputs and training to students at Degree level to handle the medical emergencies with the help of Modern Medicine as Homoeopathic Colleges and Hospitals need to have Operation Theatre, relevant equipment as well as casuality besides having the Surgeon, Gynaecologist etc. as informed to the Council by the President. After a prolonged debate, the Council members present in the meeting did not agree for providing any training in the Allopathic/Modern Medicines (Pharmacology) in Homoeopathic Colleges. The students in Homoeopathic Colleges are taught and trained to practice Homoeopathy and to understand the limitations of Homoeopathy too so that after understanding all possible diagnostic parameters and the critical stages of the disease conditions if a patient can not be relieved with Homoeopathy atleast the Homoeopathic Practitioners may tell the prognosis to patients family members or refer such patients to other concerned medical experts, if required.

Agenda Item No. 47.8

Amendments in Central Council of Homoeopathy (General) Regulations.

The Central Council deferred the matter for its next meeting.

Agenda Item No. 47.9

  1. Ministry s letter No.R.13040/10/2011-HD dated 19.08.2011 regarding implementation of provisions of Homoeopathy (Minimum Standard of Education) Regulations, 1983- Reg.
  2. Ministry s letter No.R.13040/10/2011-HD (Tech) dated 19.08.2011 addressed to Principles regarding implementation of Homoeopathy (Minimum Standard of Education) Regulations, 1983- Reg.

The Central Council considered the matter and noted the tone of correspondence in particular in the Ministry s letters. The Central Council decided to inform the Central Govt. that Homoeopathic Medical Colleges and Homoeopathic Hospitals inspected during the current financial year from April to October, 2011 may not be inspected again during Nov. 2011 but the Colleges remaining can be inspected within Nov., 2011. Moreso conducting inspection of Homoeopathic Medical Colleges only in 15 days from 1.11.2011 to 15.11.2011 even for such colleges may not be practically possible for sending the reports upto 31.12.2011 after calling compliance.

Agenda Item No. 47.10

Requests received under section 12A of Homoeopathy Central Council Act for opening of New Homoeopathic Medical College.

  • S.V.S. Medical. College of Homoeopathy & R.I., Kalla Kurichi
  • Param Himalaya H.M.C. Hospital & Research Centre, Dehradun
  • North Eastern Institute of Ayurveda and Homoeopathy, Maghalaya.

The Central Council ratified the decisions taken by Executive Committee in respect of new proposals.

Agenda Item No. 47.11

Requests received under section 12A of Homoeopathy Central Council Act for opening of New/Higher Courses.

The Central Council ratified the decisions taken by Executive Committee in respect of new proposals excluding the decision of Vamanrao Ithape Homoeopathic Medical College, Sangamner for which it decided to call compliance report and verify the same through another inspection.

Agenda Item No. 47.12

Request received under section 12A of Homoeopathy Central Council Act for increase in the intake capacity.

The Central Council ratified the decisions taken by Executive Committee in respect of new proposals.

Agenda Item No. 47.13

Consideration of Inspection Reports of Homoeopathic Medical Colleges in the states of Andhra Pradesh, Arunachal Pradesh, Assam, Bihar, Chhattisgarh, Gujarat, Haryana, Himachal Pradesh, Jharkhand, Karnataka, Kerala, Maharashtra, Madhya Pradesh, Punjab, Rajasthan, Tamil Nadu, Uttar Pradesh, Uttrakhand, West Bengal.

The Central Council ratified the decisions taken by Executive Committee in respect of various reports of inspections undertaken after its last meeting.

Agenda Item No. 47.14

Compliance Reports received from some Homoeopathic Medical Colleges in view of Shortfalls/Observation Reports sent as per following letters:-

  1. No.DKMM/I/CCH/2010/7299-A, Dated 15/12/2010
  2. No.IGM/DHAR/2010-11/418, Dated 08/04/2011
  3. No.DSHMC/209/2011-12, Dated 14/04/2011
  4. No.4339-42/College/CCH-Insp./11, Dated 03/05/2011
  5. L.No.HC/183/11-12, Dated 27/06/2011
  6. Ref.No.19009/Sjhmc/CCH.Compl.-Report-2011, Dated 30/07/2011
  7. Ref.RKDFMC/2858/11, Dated 13/07/2011
  8. Ref.LBS/551/11, Dated 10/08/11
  9. Ref.No.-SHMC/TRUST/961/11, Dated 05/08/2011
  10. Ref.No.AHMC/196/2011, Dated 06/09/2011
  11. Ref.No.336/2011, Dated 06.09.2011
  12. L.No./V.R.H./2011/1404, Dated 24/08/2011
  13. Ref.MGHMC/JBP/11/1445, Dated 25/08/2011
  14. REF.No.4081/11, Dated 25/08/2011
  15. Ref.No.1454/NCCHMCH/CH/33/2001, Dated 05/09/2011
  16. Ref.No.463/CHMC&H, Dated 13/06/2011
  17. Ref:1277/2011, Dated 25.08.2011
  18. SMC/HOM/CCH/3213/2011-2012, Dated 30.08.2011
  19. Ref.BBHMC/129/2011-12, Dated 20.06.2011
  20. Ref.No.-NHMC/2011/07-52, Dated 08/07/2011
  21. No.YPSM/CCH/2011-12, Dated 28/08/2011
  22. Ref.No.SGNR/HMC/11/1217, Dated 01/08/2011
  23. O.W.No.BHMC/1634/2011, Dated 06/09/2011
  24. GHMC/CCH-Comp/134/2011, Dated 03/09/2011
  25. Ref.No.YHMC/PG/207/2011, Dated 05/08/2011
  26. Ref.No.:DHMC/11/1778, Dated 10/05/2011
  27. Ref:MHMC/CCH/Compliance/3A/2011/401, Dated 10/05/2011
  28. Ref.No.:JMT/SHMC/902/2011, Dated 20/05/2011
  29. L.No.41/DHMC/2011, Dated 25.08.2011
  30. Ref: SRET/MIHS/CCH/11/08-03, Dated 11/08/2011
  31. Out ward No.: SMMHMC//061/11-12, Dated 26.07.2011
  32. Ref. No:CDPCHM/1/2011-12/214, Dated 25/08/2011
  33. MKSHMC/104/2011, Dated 02.09.2011
  34. MSPHMC/153/11-12, Dated 17.08.2011
  35. Ref.No.:BHMC/499/2011, Dated 15.07.2011
  36. No.HMC/891, Dated 18.08.2011
  37. Ref.No.CCQ/44(1)/10161, Dated 27.06.2011
  38. Ref.No. KHMC/2011/8582, Dated 04/08/2011

The Central Council noted the decisions of Executive Committee in the matter.

Agenda Item No. 47.15

Approval of P.G. Guides/Examiners for M.D.(Hom.) Courses in respect of different Universities.

The Central Council ratified the decisions taken by the Executive Committee in the matter. However, the Central Council approved the name of Dr.N.V.Sugathan as an approved Examiner/Guide in respect of the Tamil Nadu Dr.M.G.R.Medical University as the name of the University (awarded M.D.(Hom.) to him) has been wrongly mentioned in the document (due to typographical error) submitted by the University.

Agenda Item No. 47.16

Draft M.D. (Hom.) Course in New Subject namely, Pathology amendment in Homoeopathy (Post Graduate Degree Course)Regulations.

The Central Council approved the draft concept document for M.D.(Hom.) in Pathology and it decided that this document may be given the required shape in which it has to be in corporated in Post Graduate Degree Course Regulations.

However, the members namely, Dr.B.N.Prakash, Dr.L.K.Nanda, Dr.K.K.Kar, Dr.V.K.Khanna and Dr.Veerabramcharya gave a joint Note of Dissent which is placed at Annexure C hereto. It may be noted that the members namely Dr.B.N.Prakash, Dr.V.K.Khanna and Dr.Veerabramcharya have left the meeting before this Agenda Item was discussed by the Central Council.

Agenda Item No. 47.17

C.G.H.S. Contribution for the year 2011 - 2012 regarding.

The Central Council sanctioned Rs. 3,53,464/- payable to the CGHS authorities.

Agenda Item No. 47.18

Letter dated 17.03.2011 received from Association of Management of Homoeopathic Medical Colleges of Maharashtra regarding considering (1) the number of full time faculty for undergraduate BHMS Course, (2) Proposal for 4 year BHMS curriculum and (3) Revised pattern for non-teaching staff for only 25 bedded hospital.

The Central Council decided to defer the matter to Education Committee as to whether the suggestions given by the Association can be considered for amendments in regulations in respect of BHMS Degree Course.

The Central Council also decided that the P.G.Education Committee may examine whether the duration of M.D.(Hom.) courses (for regular student) be reduced.

Agenda Item No. 47.19

Sanction of Outsourcing Personnel.

The Central Council approved for taking services of 13 persons as Data Entry Operators/Office Assistants/Accounts Clerks from out-sourcing as recommended by the Executive Committee.

The Central Council also decided to find out whether 3 persons holding the BHMS Degree qualification as included in the Second Schedule can be taken through a similar agency by out-sourcing.

Agenda Item No. 47.20

Visit of President/Vice-President CCH to different States.

The Central Council noted about the visits of President, Vice-President and Officials of CCH to different States, and to B.A.Bihar University, Muzaffarpur.

Agenda Item No. 47.21

Workshops held by CCH during April, 2011 to September, 2011.

The Central Council noted the proceedings of the three workshops.

Agenda Item No. 47.22.

Legal Opinion regarding completion of Internship after prescribed period of maximum two years.

The Central Council though noted the legal opinion but it decided to allow all applicants who have requested during the period from April, 2011 October, 2011 for condonation of delay in internship training.

Agenda Item No. 47.23

Amendment in Homoeopathy (Degree Course) B.H.M.S. Regulations.

The Central Council re-iterated its earlier decision concerning duration of the Course.

Agenda Item No. 47.24

Ministry s letter No.14015/9/88-CCH dated 30-10-2003 regarding Amendments in Homoeopathic Practitioners (Professional Conduct, Etiquette & Code of Ethics) Regulations 1982.

The Central Council ratified the proposed amendments in Homoeopathic Practitioners (Professional conduct, Etiquette & Code of Ethics) Regulations, 1982.

Agenda Item No. 47.25

Refurnishing work of C.C.H. Office.

The Central Council noted the progress in the work concerning refurnishing of its office and it also noted the release of funds in two installments i.e. Rs. 46,87,215/- and Rs.16,00,000/- to N.P.C.C.Limited in the matter. The Central Council further decided to release another instalment of Rs. 26, 18, 493/- in favour of N.P.C.C.Limited and the remaining amount of Rs. 4,68,722/- may be kept as Security amount which will be released only after satisfying with the quality of work on completion thereof.

Agenda Item No. 47.26

Bills received from Publication Department, Delhi regarding Central Register.

The Central Council sanctioned the amount reflected in the following bills of Publication Department, Delhi received in respect of maintenance/renewal of Central Register of Homoeopathy

  • Bill No. 91 dated 9.8.2011 of Rs. 67,69,700/-
  • Bill No. 48 dated 23.6.2011 of Rs. 6100/-
  • Bill No. 27 dated 10.5.2011 of Rs. 37,800/-
  • Bill No. 56 dated 5.7.2011 of Rs. 41,300/-

Agenda Item No. 47.27

Letter No.IA (HQ) CCH (171)/2008-2009/728 dated 24.3.2011 regarding Inspection Report on account for the year 2008-2009.

The Central Council ratified the decisions taken by the Executive Committee in the matter.

Agenda Item No. 47.28

Letter dated 2.4.2011 received from Dr. P.S. Ranu, Member, CCH.

The Central Council discussed the matter and ratified the decision of Executive Committee.

However, the note of dissent of Dr.P.S.Ranu, received is attached herewith as Annexure -D.

Agenda Item No. 47.29

  • Sanction of Rs.73,456/- M/s Bedi and Bedi Associates for providing man-power during the month of March 2011.
  • Sanction of Rs.66,538/- M/s Bedi and Bedi Associates for providing man-power during the month of April 2011.
  • Sanction of Rs.64,704/- M/s Bedi and Bedi Associates for providing man-power during the month of May, 2011.
  • Sanction of Rs.66,315/- M/s Bedi and Bedi Associates for providing man-power during the month of June, 2011.
  • Sanction of Rs.63,141/- M/s Bedi and Bedi Associates for providing man-power during the month of July, 2011.
  • Sanction of Rs.86,496/- M/s Bedi and Bedi Associates for providing man-power during the month of August, 2011.
  • Sanction of Rs.88,637/- M/s Bedi and Bedi Associates for providing man-power during the month of September, 2011.

The Central Council granted expost-facto-sanction for payment of following amount to M/s. Bedi and Bedi Associates for the outsourced man power

  • Rs. 73,456/- for the month of March, 2011.
  • Rs.66,538/- for the month of April, 2011.
  • Rs. 64,704/- for the month of May, 2011
  • Rs.66,315/- for the month of June, 2011.
  • Rs.63,141/- for the month of July, 2011.
  • Rs.86,496/- for the month of August, 2011
  • Rs.88,637/- for the month of September, 2011

Agenda Item No. 47.30

Payments of Rs.1,00,000/- Post Master, HPO, New Delhi for refilling Postage Stamps in franking machine Sanction, regarding.

The Central Council granted expost-facto sanction to Rs. 1 lakh for refilling of Postage Value in the Franking Machine.

Agenda Item No. 47.31

Judgement dated 24.9.2010 of Hon ble Supreme Court in SLA (C) No.14497/2010.

Judgement dated 9.3.2010 of Hon ble High Court of Kerala in W.A. No.626 of 2007.

Judgement dated 6.12.2006 of Hon ble High Court of Kerala in W.P.C.29770/2006.

The Central Council ratified the decision of Executive Committee in the matter.

Agenda Item No. 47.31

  • Ministry s letter No.R.14013/02/2003-HD(Tech.) dated 26.3.2009 regarding inclusion of M.D.(Hom.) Degree qualification awarded by Maharashtra University of Health Sciences, Nashik in the Second Schedule to HCC Act, 1973.
  • Letter No.MUHS/PG/E4/1632/2011 dated 28.7.2011 received from Maharashtra University of Health Sciences, Nashik regarding inclusion of M.D.(Hom.) qualification awarded by the University in the Second Schedule of HCC Act, 1973.

The Central Council ratified the decisions of Executive Committee in the matter.

 

Agenda Item No. 47.32

  • Ministry's letter No.R.14013/02/2003-HD(Tech.) dated 26.3.2009 regarding inclusion of M.D.(Hom.) Degree qualification awarded by Maharashtra University of Health Sciences, Nashik in the Second Schedule to HCC Act, 1973.
  • Letter No.MUHS/PG/E4/1632/2011 dated 28.7.2011 received from Maharashtra University of Health Sciences, Nashik regarding inclusion of M.D.(Hom.) qualification awarded by the University in the Second Schedule of HCC Act, 1973.

The Central Council ratified the decisions of Executive Committee in the matter.

 

Agenda Item No. 47.33

Ministry s letter No.R.13040/45/2010-HD (Tech.) dated 15.7.2011 regarding inclusion of BHMS Degree qualification awarded by Maharshi Dayanand University, Rohtak in the Second Schedule of HCC Act, 1973.

The Central Council ratified the decision of Executive Committee in the matter.

Agenda Item No. 47.34

Ministry s letter No.R.13040/93/2008-HD (Tech.) dated 2.5.2011 regarding inclusion of BHMS Degree awarded by the West Bengal University of Health Sciences in Second Schedule.

The Central Council ratified the decision of Executive Committee in the matter.

Agenda Item No. 47.35

Letter dated 25.03.2011 received from Dr. A.P. Verma regarding Slogan.

The Central Council ratified the decision of Executive Committee in the matter.

Agenda Item No. 47.36

Amendments in Post Graduate Degree Course, Regulations, 1983.

The Central Council reiterated its decision taken in the meeting on 25.3.2011 regarding the duration of the Courses.

Agenda Item No. 47.37

Letter No.LIGA 2011/04//Correspondence/06 dated 28.7.2011 received from LMHI for requesting CCH to nominate the Officers to participate in the Congress

The Central Council ratified the decision taken by the Executive Committee for bearing the expenses for deputing its Officers to attend the LIGA Congress and also for having a stall of CCH therein at the expense of Rs. 50,000/- paid by the Council.

Agenda Item No. 47.38

Ministry s Letter No.R.Z.28015/60/201-P&C dated 30th June, 2011 regarding Padma Awards namely Padma Vibhushan, Padma Bhushan, and Padma Shri to be announced on the occasion of Republic Day -2012.

The Central Council ratified the decision of Executive Committee in the matter.

Agenda Item No. 47.39

Letter dated 04.12.2010 received from Prof. Dr. M.K.Sahni, Member, CCH regarding proposal for publication of Journal

The Central Council approved the names of the Editorial Board i.e. Dr.C.Nayak, Dr.Arvind Kothe, Dr.Mridul Kumar Sahani, Dr.L.K.Nanda and Dr.M.R.Srivatsan as the Editorial Board of the proposed publication of CCH with the name of Indian Journal of Homoeopathic Education and Research. It also agreed for not fixing any price of the proposed journal for atleast two years and the journal may be published in English and/or Hindi if the original article received happen to be in English or Hindi but the journal may not be published bilingually.

Agenda Item No. 47.40

Ministry s letter No.R.13040/17/2006-HD dated 22.12.2010 regarding inclusion of BHMS qualification awarded by Dr. Hari Singh Gour University, Sagar in 2nd Schedule of H.C.C. Act, 1973.

The Central Council ratified the decision of Executive Committee in the matter.

Agenda Item No. 47.41

Ministry s letter No. R.13040/7/2006-HD(Tech) dated 1.08.2011 regarding inclusion of M.D. (Hom.) qualification awarded by Hemchandracharya North Gujarat University, Patna in the Second Schedule of HCC Act, 1973

The Central Council ratified the decision of Executive Committee in the matter.

Agenda Item No. 47.42

Ministry s letter No. R.13014/01/2007-EP dated March, 2007 regarding stopping admission in Bihar Homoeopathic Medical College, Patna.

The Central Council ratified the decision of Executive Committee in the matter.

Agenda Item No. 47.43

Amendment in Standing Orders.

The Central Council ratified the decision of Executive Committee in the matter.

Agenda Item No. 47.44

Minutes of the Meeting of the P.G. Education Committee of CCH on 23.04.2011 at Beed (M.S.).

The Central Council ratified the decisions of P.G.Education Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere in these minutes.

Agenda Item No. 47.45

Minutes of the Meeting of the Regulation Committee of CCH on 04.05.2011 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the decisions of Regulation Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere in these minutes.

Agenda Item No. 47.46

Minutes of the 147th Meeting of the Executive Committee of CCH on 31.05.2011 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the decisions of Executive Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere in these minutes.

Agenda Item No. 47.47

Minutes of the P.G. Education Committee of CCH on 14.06.2011 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the decisions of P.G.Education Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere in these minutes.

Agenda Item No. 47.48

Minutes of the Meeting of the Education Committee of CCH on 21.07.2011 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the decisions of Education Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere in these minutes.

Agenda Item No. 47.49

Minutes of the Meeting of the 148th Meeting of the Executive Committee of CCH on 28.07.2011 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the decisions of Executive Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere in these minutes.

Agenda Item No. 47.50

Minutes of the Meeting of the Registration Committee of CCH on 01.08.2011 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the decisions of Registration Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere in these minutes.

Agenda Item No. 47.51

Minutes of the Meeting of the Office Functioning Review Committee of CCH on 09.08.2011 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the decisions of Office Functioning Review Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere in these minutes.

Agenda Item No. 47.52

Minutes of the meeting of Rajbhasa (Hindi) Committee held on 10.08.2011 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the decisions of Rajbhasa (Hindi) Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere in these minutes.

Agenda Item No. 47.53

Minutes of the Meeting of the Literature Committee of CCH on 18.08.2011 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the decision of Literature Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere in these minutes.

Agenda Item No. 47.54

Minutes of the Meeting of the Finance Committee of CCH dated 21.09.211 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the decisions of Finance Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere in these minutes.

Agenda Item No. 47.55

Minutes of the Meeting of P.G. Education Committee of CCH dated 22.09.2011 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the decisions of P.G. Education Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere in these minutes.

Agenda Item No. 47.56

Minutes of the Meeting of the 149th Executive Committee of CCH dated 23.09.2011 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the decisions of Executive Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere in these minutes. Regarding Item No. 149.6, the Central Council while ratifying the decision of Executive Committee, further decided to request the Department of AYUSH, Govt. of India to sanction P.G.Allowance and Annual Allowance to the concerned Officers of C.C.H. retrospectively, as there had been no fault of these officers. The Central Govt. may extend the said allowances/facility being given to its officers also to the concerned officers of CCH.

Dr.P.S.Ranu, Member, has given a note showing his restrain in respect of the report of inspection of Baliraja Shikshan Prasarak Mandals Padmashree Shymaji Kadam Homoeopathic Medical College, Nanded which has been taken into the Councils record.

Agenda Item No. 47.57

Minutes of the Meeting of the Education Committee of CCH dated 07.10.2011 at New Delhi

The Central Council ratified the decisions of Education Committee which have not been discussed elsewhere in these minutes.

Agenda Item No. 47.58

Minutes of the 150th Meeting of Executive Committee of CCH to be held on 17th October 2011 at New Delhi.

The Central Council ratified the decision of Executive Committee in respect of its meeting held on 17.10.2011 except item No. 151.9.15.2. and for this Agenda Item concerning Vamanrao Ithape Homoeopathic Medical College, Sangamner, it decided to verify the compliance report and the Executive Committee may decide the report of inspection of verification of the compliance report.

SUPPLEMENTARY AGENDA

Agenda Item No. 47.59.1

Payment above Rs. 50,000/-

The Central Council granted expost-facto-sanction to Rs. 1 lakh which has been incurred in filling up the Postal value in the Franking Machine of the Council.

  • M/s. K.S.Info systems for purchase of two computers
  • M/s.Innovation System for installation of Wi-FI Systems (Rs. 40,000/- paid as per part payment
  • CCH Pension Fund Account out of Internal Resources to strengthen Pension Fund in view of recommendations of Finance Committee.

The Central Council also sanctioned the following amounts payable to the Agencies named below:-

Agenda Item No. 47.59.2

Ministry s letter No.R.13040/10/2011-HD (Tech.)(Part) dated 27.5.2011 regarding poor admission in BHMS Degree Course at National Level Involvement of CBSE in BHMS admissions.

The Central Council decided to defer the matter for its next meeting.

Any other item with the permission of the Chair.

  • It has been decided to include Dr.S.N.Sinha, Member in the Sub-Committee concerning the work of CCH website, and to include Dr.B.Sohan Singh, Member in the Sub-Committee constituted regarding the inspection report works. Meeting ended with a vote of thanks to the Chair.

Sd/-

(Dr.Lalit Verma)

Secretary

Attested

Sd/-

(Dr.Ramjee Singh)

President

Annexure-B

FURTHER AMENDMENT PROPOSED IN HOMOEPATHY (MINIMUM STANDARDS OF EDUCATION) REGULATIONS DURING THE MEETING OF CENTRAL COUNCIL OF HOMOEOPATHY HELD ON 21.10.2011 AT NEW DELHI.

The Central Council of Homoeopathy did not agree for dividing para-meters for teaching faculty strength as such strength recommended for teaching faculty upto 100 is re-iterated.

In respect of Regulation 3 it decided to modify as under :-

There shall be a Homoeopathic Hospital with each Homoeopathic College of not less than 25 beds having the requirements, norm and standards as specified in these regulations in regard to teaching as well as Hospital staff, equipment, accommodation, training and other facilities and it shall have also one peripheral homoeopathic clinic for every 10 admissions. For exposure to the students in the clinical field and to understand the depth of operative surgery and operative Gynecology/Obst.as well as management in critical illnesses, a homoeopathic college shall have an attachment with a reputed near by located super specialty hospital (of modern medicine) with all required facilities of operation theater, labor room, ICU and other required facilities for the management of critical patients. In case a Homoeopathic Hospital of Homoeopathic College does not have the facilities to handle operation theatre and other critical patients, the students of such a college can be deputed under the strict supervision of concerned teaching faculty of the college for the required exposure in the said field to the attached super specialty hospital .

However, the proposed proviso in respect of said regulation shall remain as such.

In respect of Annexure F , following have been the recommendations of the Council

  • Demonstration of dissected parts may be stressed in place of Dissection to be performed on cadavers.
  • Since a Centralised Audio Visual Department has been proposed in a college, as such separate OHP, LCD Projector, Web-Camera etc. in each department may not be insisted as such items may be provided in the said Centralised Audio Visual Department.
  • In the Department of Physiology
    • Colour Perception Lantern (Ebridge Green) need to be omitted.
    • The number of Haematocrit Tubes and Haemoglobinometer Sahli, and Haemocytometer -10 each will be sufficient.
  • In Lab. of Biochemistry -
    • Blood, Urea, Estimation Apparatus (complete) may be omitted.
    • Water baths, with Lids having 8 +12 holes metal 2 may be sufficient.
    • Albuminometer 10 may be sufficient.
    • Double Distillation Apparatus Glass 1 may be sufficient.
    • Chromatography Unit/TLC Plate may be omitted.
  • In respect of Department of Pathology, the following may be omitted
    • Rotary Microtome.
    • Water Bath 57 C.
    • Rectangular Water Bath.
    • Automatic Tissue Processor.

The following may be sufficient in 10 number

  • Haemocytometer with RBC & WBC Pipettes.
  • Haemoglobinometer Sahli.
  • Microscopes with Oil Immersion or LCD Display.
  • Under the Heading of Forensic Medicine and Toxiocology Department, at S.No. (3), the word Equipments may be read as Equipment . The chemicals listed in the proposed amendments may be omitted. The list of House Hold poisons may be as under:-
    • Deodorant spray.
    • Gin
    • Rum
    • Whisky
    • Shampoo
    • Toilet Cleaner
    • Moth Repellent
    • Shoe polish
    • Acetone Pure
    • Anti septic germicide
    • Spirit
    • Cough-Syrup
    • Thinner
    • Insecticide
    • Agro-Insecticide Malathion
    • Sunscreen lotion
    • Napthalene Balls
    • Cough Lozenzes
    • Boric acid Powder
    • Rat poison
    • Wax crayons
  • In the Department of Homeopathic Pharmacy
    • Simple Microscope 10 may be added
    • Following may be required in 25 number
      • Pill tiles
      • Porecelain Dishes
      • Crucibles with tongs
      • Pestles and mortars (Iron, Glass, Procelain).
      • Measure Glasses all size
    • Water Bath, Metal/Electric 10 number may be sufficient.
  • In Department of Organon of Medicine, under the heading Charts on Pioneers, at number 16 the spellings of “Farrningtan” will be corrected as “Farrnington”. Under the heading Charts on Organon of Medicine and Homoeopathic Philosophy, the suggested charts at number 45 and 55 may be omitted.
  • In Department of Repertory, 10 computers with accessories and 5 available soft wares on Repertory - may be added.
  • In respect of Articles for operation theater
    • At number 12 the words “Dunlop mattress” may be written as “Mattress (Foam/Spongy/Coir).
    • S.No. 37 may be omitted.